Telehealth 'three times over NICE cost limit'

Telehealth is unlikely to provide value for money for the NHS unless equipment costs fall dramatically, research suggests.

Adult pulse oximeter (blood oxygen meter) fitted to the finger of an adult to measure pulse rate and oxygen concentration of the blood. (SPL)

An analysis by the London School of Economics (LSE) found the health-monitoring devices cost around £92,000 per year of good quality life gained – three times the level NICE recommends as cost effective.

Researchers said equipment costs needed to fall by up to 80% before the planned national telehealth roll-out would become cost effective.

The DH said it is working with industry to bring down equipment costs to create a ‘sustainable’ service.

The department wants millions of people to benefit from telehealth and telecare services, and launched the Three Million Lives campaign in January alongside industry to begin a large-scale roll-out.

Last month, the first findings from the DH-funded Whole System Demonstrator trial found telehealth could reduce hospital admissions and deaths. But researchers found no evidence the technology could reduce NHS costs.

Catherine Henderson, an LSE researcher, presented early findings from a separate economic analysis of the trial at a Westminster Health Forum event in London on Tuesday.

Her team compared the likely benefit to patients to the costs of equipment, support and infrastructure needed to run the service at the time of the trial in 2009/10.

Their analysis, which is yet to be peer reviewed, found telehealth would cost around £92,000 per quality-adjusted life year (QALY), the measure used by NICE to calculate the value of a drug or other medical product to the NHS.

The watchdog has traditionally rejected drugs and other medical devices when this value climbs above £20,000-£30,000.

'Unlikely to save costs'
Ms Henderson said: ‘On the basis of the results we concluded that it’s unlikely that the telehealth intervention is cost effective in terms of improving quality of life, in reference to the NICE willingness-to-pay threshold, the QALY.’

The average annual cost was £1,850 per patient per year. Equipment costs are beginning to fall, Ms Henderson added, but would need to drop by 50% to 80% for a telehealth service to provide good value to the NHS.

Even if prices fell by this amount, she said, there was only a 61% chance telehealth would be cost effective in the ‘most optimistic scenario’.

Stephen Johnson, DH deputy director of long-term conditions, said the department was working with industry to lower the cost of the devices. ‘We want a sustainable approach that gives this a fighting chance to work,’ he said. ‘We’ve got the evidence, but what is the business case?’

He added: ‘What we’ve got to do is work out how to make this cost effective.’

Mr Johnson revealed that private telehealth companies will earn revenue for each patient referred into a telehealth scheme as part of these arrangements.

He said the telehealth industry would help create care pathways for GP commissioners to follow.

Internal DH calculations uncovered by GP last month showed the department assumes equipment costs will fall to an average of £500 per unit. It calculated that at this price telehealth would need to save £70-£543 per patient to achieve £1.2bn savings predicted by ministers in March.

Further analyses from the Whole System Demonstrator trial will be published over the coming months.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Just published


NICE moves CVD advice closer to QOF and updates treatment escalation options

NICE draft guidance on cardiovascular disease backs a new target for lipid levels...

GP surgery sign

GP alert system shows practices under major pressure

General practice has moved up to an 'OPEL 3' pressure rating nationally with two...

Podcast: How making your practice a better place to work can improve patient care

Sheffield GP Dr Ben Allen explains how focusing on staff and improving his practice's...

X-ray sign

Spike in TB cases prompts public health warning

Cases of TB in England have risen by 7% compared with last year, prompting a warning...

COVID-19 vaccine

GPs demand investigation as winter vaccine 'mismanagement' risks patient safety

GP leaders in England have demanded an investigation into 'mismanagement' of this...

Medical centre sign

GP 'engineering' fears as small practice contracts offered on branch-only basis

GP leaders have raised concerns over the 'engineering' of general practice after...