A serious case of a second opinion

Mrs Cross was not happy. Her blood tests were all normal.

I had done my spiel on calories and she still wanted to know why she had a big stomach. Someone had scanned it, so determined was she that its growth was independent of her energy intake, but our colleagues in ultrasound had convincingly demonstrated a hearty layer of fat and now Mrs Cross wanted to know how I was going to get rid of it. She had put on half a stone.

The news that the words 'all' and 'bugger' described my planned response did not go down well. Mrs Cross thought I wasn't taking things seriously.

It's a GP problem. We hone our strategies for dealing with this sort of query until they are as shiny as a policeman's helmet badge, and then we offer them up with care. Yet sometimes it goes down with the gently convincing charm of a 30 foot concrete hippopotamus fired from a catapult.

There is a point, though, when we can do no more. What then when the patient glares challengingly, elbows the metaphorical hippo aside as if it were a feather boa, and says: 'Well I'd like a second opinion.'

What are the options? There's plan A - tempting - to respond that my second opinion is exactly the same as my first. Plan B - give her what she wants. (I wander, Dr Who-like into a parallel Universe in which I cry: 'My God, I should have seen it at once. Your Serious gland is exploding. We must rush you to Colchester for a panproctoseriousectomy, from which you will emerge looking like Claudia Schiffer, only with even better hair.'). Sadly there are obvious problems with Plan B and I regretfully ditch it.

Plan C involves passing her on to a consultant who will hate me until he retires, and I don't yet know who's the oldest consultant in Colchester, and there isn't a Plan D. I meet her gaze squarely and explain this until she leaves in a huff. There are days when without chocolate I am nothing.

Dr Selby, a GP in Suffolk. You can write to her at GPcolumnists@haymarket.com

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus