Seasonal jab 'may increase swine flu risk'

Seasonal flu jabs may increase risk of infection with the H1N1 flu strain, researchers say.

Swine flu: jab may increase risk
Swine flu: jab may increase risk

But they called for further work to prove the link was 'real and causal'.

Canadian researchers analysed data from four studies, conducted by the country's public health agencies in response to a local outbreak in spring-summer 2009.

The researchers looked at whether 2,731 people included in the studies were more likely to contract pandemic flu if they had been given the trivalent influenza vaccine (TIV) in the 2008/9 flu season.

The results of one study showed that TIV helped protect recipients against seasonal flu.

However, combined data from all four studies showed there was a 1.4to 2.5-fold increased likelihood of pandemic flu illness among those given the seasonal flu vaccine the previous year, compared with those who had not. The researchers noted, however, that the studies do not show whether this was a causal link or simply the result of a methodological bias.

Authors said that because the result was contrary to established knowledge, greater scrutiny was needed to determine whether the results were real.

They added: 'If these observations do reflect a real biological effect, however, they raise important questions that warrant further scientific investigation.'

However, the WHO has recommended the pandemic flu strain be included in the seasonal flu vaccine, which would provide protection and preclude the risks identified in the study.

In an accompanying editorial, researchers from the National Institutes of Health said: 'Given the uncertainty associated with observational studies, we believe it would be premature to conclude that (the vaccine) increased risk of 2009 pandemic illness.'

This was in light of six other contemporaneous observational studies in civilian populations that have produced highly conflicting results, they added.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

LMCs demand renegotiation of COVID-19 enhanced service deal

LMCs demand renegotiation of COVID-19 enhanced service deal

LMCs have called for a renegotiation of funding for the COVID-19 vaccination enhanced...

LMCs demand ballot of profession on PCN DES ahead of next contract talks

LMCs demand ballot of profession on PCN DES ahead of next contract talks

LMCs have demanded a ballot of GPs on the primary care network (PCN) DES before BMA...

Lack of support left locums at physical and financial risk in pandemic, say LMCs

Lack of support left locums at physical and financial risk in pandemic, say LMCs

Locum GPs have faced significant physical and financial risk because of a lack of...

LMCs demand NHS England apology over ‘abhorrent' claims about general practice

LMCs demand NHS England apology over ‘abhorrent' claims about general practice

LMCs have called on NHS England to apologise for ‘abhorrent and insulting’ suggestions...

CCGs to be stripped of commissioning role under reforms backed by NHS England

CCGs to be stripped of commissioning role under reforms backed by NHS England

CCGs could be stripped of their commissioning role under plans set out by NHS England,...

Shielding advice updated to reflect return to tiered system on 2 December

Shielding advice updated to reflect return to tiered system on 2 December

The government has updated its guidance for patients on the shielding list to reflect...