Revalidation - Robust clinical governance is key

It is time to put your practice through a rigorous rules review, advises Professor Ruth Chambers.

Professor Ruth Chambers
Professor Ruth Chambers

This summer saw the publication of the CMO for England Sir Liam Donaldson's 'Medical Revalidation - Principles and Next Steps'.

With the tightening of professional regulation of all doctors and relicensing/recertification of GPs now on the horizon for 2009 onwards, this is the time to refresh the clinical governance framework in your practice.

Your primary care organisation (PCO) will also be looking at clinical governance, gearing up for its part in relicensing the doctors on the performers' list. As the PCO builds up information about individual doctors' performance, the likelihood is that more concerns about doctors' conduct and performance will be generated.

Demonstrating high quality
If you can show you and your practice provide consistently high quality primary care services, you can leave the worrying about revalidation to other GPs - you should sail through. You could embrace one or more of the initiatives under 'Building momentum', see right, to help improve quality in your practice.

Affirming your fitness
While revalidation is about affirming that you as an individual doctor are fit to practise, working in a well-organised practice environment where standards of best practice are the norm will enable you to easily gather evidence of your own good performance.

If you trust the process you will feel confident about acknowledging any gaps in your knowledge and skills and openly addressing them. Also your practice team will learn lessons from any patient complaint and minimise the chance of adverse events recurring.

Building up momentum
The emphasis on quality improvement at all practices is coming from several directions as well as the national momentum around professional regulation. These include competition from private providers and bids for Darzi practices that are angled at raising quality standards. Then there is the RCGP pilot to accredit primary care provider practices.

This is setting criteria for practices to attain in tackling health inequalities and health promotion; provider management; premises, records, equipment and medicines management; provider teams; learning organisation; and patient experience/involvement.

Updating criteria
At present the criteria, standards and evidence for GP recertification are being updated to match the revised 'Good Medical Practice for GPs' recently published by the RCGP/GPC.

Across the UK there are PCOs evolving strategies that set higher standards than the quality framework with incentives to encourage take up.

We can also expect possible future inspection of practices when the Care Quality Commission is established next year.

Investing in better care
Clinical governance is central to your practice team's ability to continuous improving the quality of services and to safeguarding high standards of care.

Investing in clinical governance is about focusing clinical services on continuous quality improvement; patient safety; risk reduction and, without detriment to the other three components, minimising costs.

You should be able to use the dimensions below to review the state of clinical governance in your practice.

  • Professor Chambers is a GP and professor of health development at Staffordshire University
  • for 'Medical revalidation - principles and next step', report of the CMO for England's working group

Book offer
GPs can buy 'Revalidation: prepare now and get it right' by R Chambers, G Wakley and P Bright published by Radcliffe Publishing for £14.96 (25 per cent discount) plus p&p by calling 01235 528820 and quoting GP Discount.

Or, if buying online at, key in GP Discount when prompted to pay.

Dimensions for the practice to focus on
Practice Governance

  • Good employment rules observed.
  • Professional codes of conduct respected.
  • Equality and diversity respected.
  • Resources sufficient to provide best clinical practice.
  • Access and availability suitable for patient population.
  • Patient confidentiality processes in place.

Culture: leadership, teamwork and communication

  • Regular multi-disciplinary team meetings.
  • Good, clearly identified, robust clinical leadership.
  • Good communications with primary care organisations.
  • Good relationship with linked professionals and local community.

Education and training

  • Practice staff competent in their roles; and trained for new tasks proactively.
  • Regular appraisal and personal development planning.
  • Multisource feedback by colleagues - with facilitated reflection/personal change guidance.
  • Statutory and mandatory training in place for all staff; and is monitored for compliance.

Patients' Feedback and Involvement

  • Public notices; email/website; telephone reception; leaflets.
  • Patient surveys undertaken; suggestions from patients collated.
  • Patient participation group operates in meaningful way.

Staff have good interaction skills.

  • Translation services available/used; good patient literature in common languages of patient population available.
  • Complaints policy in place and regularly monitored for patterns/trends and effectiveness.

Clinical and Service Outcomes

  • Evidence-based practice provided for individual patients - audits demonstrate adherence.
  • Individual professionals adhere to best practice (as in local or practice protocols).
  • Clinical audit activity demonstrates outcomes of clinical care. These are monitored, acted on and evaluated for impact.

Risk Management, Patient Safety and Incident Reporting

  • Policies in place and adherence monitored for: infection control, child protection; health and safety; lone working; chaperons.
  • All incidents assessed for cause; action agreed to remedy or minimise risk of future occurrence.
  • Significant adverse event or critical incident analysis with regular-timed meetings; and with at least three professionals/staff present.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

Government tax advisers suggest removing annual allowance cap on pensions

Government tax advisers suggest removing annual allowance cap on pensions

The annual allowance cap on pension contributions could be scrapped for defined benefit...

Palpitations - red flag symptoms

Palpitations - red flag symptoms

What are the red flag symptoms to look out for when patients present with palpitations?...

Map: How GP practice list size varies across England

Map: How GP practice list size varies across England

GP practice list sizes have been rising steadily across England over the past decade...

Practice funding 'simply not enough to meet patient needs', warns BMA's top GP

Practice funding 'simply not enough to meet patient needs', warns BMA's top GP

Persistent underfunding of general practice has left practices struggling to address...

PCNs must not put CCG meetings ahead of local engagement, warns primary care director

PCNs must not put CCG meetings ahead of local engagement, warns primary care director

Primary care network (PCN) clinical directors who prioritise CCG meetings over spending...

Doctors face mental health crisis amid rising pressure, warns BMA report

Doctors face mental health crisis amid rising pressure, warns BMA report

NHS doctors are facing a mental health crisis because of unprecedented pressure from...