Revalidation is 'professional Darwinism' that is damaging patient care

Revalidation is a form of 'professional Darwinism' that is threatening the future of relationship-based care by GPs, the conference heard.

Professor Trisha Greenhalgh (Photo: Pete Hill)
Professor Trisha Greenhalgh (Photo: Pete Hill)

Professor Trisha Greenhalgh told the RCGP’s annual conference in Liverpool that the college needed to overturn the ‘unintended consequences’ of revalidation that was driving doctors out of the profession.

‘How many excellent GPs do we know who have thrown in the towel, in some cases five or ten years early, rather than do battle with the system?

‘To retain only those GPs with the inclination and stamina to play the managerialist revalidation game is an alarmingly powerful form of professional Darwinism.’

Professor Greenhalgh, from Barts and the London School of Medicine and Dentistry, warned that relationship based care was also threatened by the shift towards a marketised healthcare system where the sick patient is a customer.

‘In this market model, the doctor-patient relationship is accorded no special status, and good clinical practice is defined largely in terms of information sharing, transparency and an end to medical paternalism.’

‘In reality, most of medical care is not about making decisions. Health problems increasingly involve chronic diseases that require ongoing effort by both patients in the form of self management and professionals in the form of periodical check-ups, management of exacerbations and long-term support.’

Professor Greenhalgh also argued that the over-use of ‘unreal’ situations in medical education, such as simulated patients and standardised scenarios, was a threat to relationship-based care.

‘I know that a structured approach makes both teaching and assessment more consistent and reproducible. But I also know that what honed my own professional virtues was early and prolonged contact with real patients, suffering from real illnesses, real anxieties and real social situations, and shadowing experienced doctors caring for those patients.

‘As a college we owe it to tomorrow’s patients and tomorrow’s doctors to take a stand on the inexorable retreat of medical education from the messy, non-standardisable reality of illness and suffering.’

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

GP dilemma: What should I do if a parent sends their child with COVID-19 symptoms to school?

GP dilemma: What should I do if a parent sends their child with COVID-19 symptoms to school?

Medical Protection's Dr Clare Devlin offers advice on how GPs should respond to parents...

GPs risk missing out on vital COVID-19 risk assessments, BMA warns

GPs risk missing out on vital COVID-19 risk assessments, BMA warns

GPs risk missing out on COVID-19 risk assessments unless practices are guaranteed...

GPs call for partial suspension of network DES amid heavy workload

GPs call for partial suspension of network DES amid heavy workload

GPs leading primary care networks (PCNs) have called for the partial suspension of...

UK COVID-19 alert level raised as GPs prioritised for testing

UK COVID-19 alert level raised as GPs prioritised for testing

The government has raised the UK's COVID-19 alert level to four amid reports that...

UK on course for 50,000 COVID-19 cases a day by mid-October

UK on course for 50,000 COVID-19 cases a day by mid-October

The UK could see 50,000 COVID-19 cases per day by mid-October, with the epidemic...

Stricter short-term COVID-19 measures needed to avoid second national lockdown, BMA warns

Stricter short-term COVID-19 measures needed to avoid second national lockdown, BMA warns

COVID-19 infection rates will ‘soar’ and the NHS will ‘once again be crippled’ if...