RCGP chairwoman warns commissioners could 'outsource' care for high-cost patients

NHS reforms in England will undermine GPs' role as patient advocates and could force commissioners to 'outsource' care for high-cost patients to companies, the RCGP chairwoman has warned.

Dr Gerada: 'The UK government should improve and protect the NHS and its achievements.’
Dr Gerada: 'The UK government should improve and protect the NHS and its achievements.’

Dr Clare Gerada fears that clinical commissioning groups (CCGs) may use ‘risk stratification tools’ similar to those used by US health management organisations to identify potentially expensive patients.

These patients could then find their care ‘outsourced to third parties such as disease management companies’, Dr Gerada wrote in this month’s BJGP.

Dr Gerada said CCGs could cherry-pick fit, healthy and younger patients because they are cheaper and would deliver more profits.

She said: 'Patients with complex co-morbidities may find their care being managed by a multiplicity of disease management systems, all designed, not to improve care, but to increase the management firm's profits.

'Care for patients will be fragmented and continuity compromised due to perverse funding arrangements.'

Dr Gerada argued that GPs should be involved in planning care, but that ‘ it does not make sense for GPs to spend their time negotiating contracts with other doctors, managers, and hospitals, and even less to bear financial risk for their expensively ill patients’.

‘It turns GPs into rationers of care and away from their professional role as patient advocates,’ she warned.

Dr Gerada also predicted that mergers between CCGs would be 'inevitable' as high-cost patients could force smaller groups into bankruptcy.

She added that CCGs could also introduce personal health budgets that would see vouchers given to patients for ‘year-of-life-care’.

But she warned that evidence from the US shows co-payments increase bureaucracy, do not save money and could ‘disproportionately increase death rates among the poor and chronically ill’. 

She said: ‘Rather than trying to implement the US’s failed market-based model... the UK government should improve and protect the NHS and its achievements.’

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

GPs face tax problems as missed pension deadline forces PCSE apology

GPs face tax problems as missed pension deadline forces PCSE apology

Many GPs could struggle to plan for retirement after Primary Care Support England...

Patients who refuse to wear a mask could be denied face-to-face GP appointment

Patients who refuse to wear a mask could be denied face-to-face GP appointment

Patients who refuse to wear a face covering when attending a GP practice could be...

No plans for most GPs to open over August bank holiday, NHS England confirms

No plans for most GPs to open over August bank holiday, NHS England confirms

GP practices will not be asked to work over the August bank holiday unless they are...

More than one in five GPs have had COVID-19, poll suggests

More than one in five GPs have had COVID-19, poll suggests

More than one in five GPs may have had COVID-19, according to a BMA survey that shows...

Half of GP partners believe PCNs will improve patient care in the coming year

Half of GP partners believe PCNs will improve patient care in the coming year

Over half of GP partners believe primary care networks (PCNs) will have a positive...

GPs call for PCN mental health recruitment to be fast-tracked as cases surge

GPs call for PCN mental health recruitment to be fast-tracked as cases surge

Primary care networks (PCNs) must not be forced to wait until 2021 to recruit mental...