QOF pay slashed in England's most deprived areas

A statistical blunder that skewed QOF payments has slashed practice earnings in some of England's most deprived areas, GP can reveal.

Dr Drage: practices may be able to challenge losses to QOF pay (Photograph: JH Lancy)
Dr Drage: practices may be able to challenge losses to QOF pay (Photograph: JH Lancy)

Prevalence adjustments to QOF pay were designed to redistribute funds to support workload in areas with higher disease incidence.

But in 2009/10 the system was skewed so badly that almost all practices in England received identical pay weighting in eight clinical domains including diabetes, mental health, dementia and cardiovascular disease. Pay across all clinical domains was affected to some degree.

Data from the NHS Information Centre show an average-sized practice with high disease prevalence received up to £13,000 less per clinical domain than if raw prevalence weighting had been used, as it will be in 2010/11.

Dr Brian Karet, RCGP diabetes lead, said: ‘It’s clearly not fair: GPs should be aware of this and kick up a fuss when this is happening. The people who are monitoring QOF must iron out errors in remuneration.’

The problem largely stems from a delay between annual data collection dates. Prevalence data is recorded three months after list sizes, allowing prevalence rates to artificially inflate in this time.

Obesity prevalence hit 521% in one practice last year. This anomaly meant that a mechanism meant to protect low-prevalence practices awarded 99% of practices identical pay per point for obesity regardless of actual disease prevalence.

GP revealed earlier this year how growing lists at Darzi centres generated the high prevalence rates. But the full extent of the problem has only now become clear.

Dr Michelle Drage, joint chief executive of Londonwide LMCs, said the phasing out of the square rooting formula that weighted QOF pay until 2008/9 had been ill-timed. Challenges to recoup practice losses remain a possibility, she added.

GPC Wales chairman Dr David Bailey admitted the QOF problems were ‘bizarre’.

Stoke GP Dr Graham Johnston, whose practice has high rate of diabetes, said it was unfair practices such as his received the same pay per point as practices with far lower prevalence.

‘We’d all like QOF to be equitable and reflect the work we put in,’ he said.

Dementia was the worst affected domain last year: 99.7% of all practices fell within the same pay weighting.

From April 2010, raw prevalence will be used and should remove the influence of outliers.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

PCN development undermined by lack of local autonomy, report warns

PCN development undermined by lack of local autonomy, report warns

Primary care network (PCN) development is being undermined because they lack the...

Breast pain - red flag symptoms

Breast pain - red flag symptoms

Breast pain in women and men has a variety of possible causes, from prescription...

Workload crisis looms as GPs prepare for biggest flu campaign ever and winter COVID spike

Workload crisis looms as GPs prepare for biggest flu campaign ever and winter COVID spike

GPs face a surge in workload over the coming months as the government rolls out the...

11-day delay for mandatory face coverings will endanger lives, doctors warn

11-day delay for mandatory face coverings will endanger lives, doctors warn

Government plans to make face coverings mandatory in shops from 24 July should be...

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

GPonline provides an overview of the key guidance relating to coronavirus, including...

GPs warned over prescribing beyond their competence as hospitals shift workload

GPs warned over prescribing beyond their competence as hospitals shift workload

GPs must resist pressure to prescribe medication outside their competence and push...