Personal health budgets risk spiralling costs and fraud, warn experts

DH plans to give patients personal budgets to spend on their healthcare risk costs spiralling out of control and patients defrauding the system, according to experts.

A similar scheme in the Netherlands led to a surge in costs as the number of users jumped 10-fold within eight years, according to European public health experts. There were also 'credible reports of fraud' among users, they said.

England must learn from the Dutch system to avoid similar problems, they wrote in a BMJ analysis.

Personal health budgets, which give patients control of a budget to purchase the type of care they want to receive, are being piloted in 64 PCTs ahead of planned roll-out in April 2014.

Health secretary Andrew Lansley has said this will give patients more control over the care and support they get.

But a similar scheme in the Netherlands has been branded 'unsustainable' by the country's Ministry of Health, researchers said.

They wrote: 'If the English proposals are to succeed they will have to establish clear rules and regulations, along with adequate support to enable people to administer their budgets independently, without specialised private agencies," say the authors.

Researchers continue: 'The UK government must also recognise that personal budgets can create new demand.

'Consequently, eligibility rules and entitlements should be evaluated carefully to avoid creating false expectations and potentially disappointing many people'.

The Dutch system, introduced in 1997, led to a 10-fold increase in the number of budget holders in 2002-10, from 13,000 to 130,000. Spending on the scheme rose 23% per year, from €400m to €2.2bn in this time.

Concerns were raised by the growth of companies that broker arrangements between clients and providers, they wrote.

These and other concerns have led to large-scale reorganisation of the Dutch system, including restricting access to only those who would have otherwise entered a care home.

Warning about England's plans, the experts said: 'Unless the lessons of the Dutch experience are learnt, the unintended and negative consequences will outnumber the positive, empowering role of personal budgets.'

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

GP consulting room

Nine in ten GPs fear their practice will struggle to cope this winter

Nearly nine in ten GPs fear that their practice will struggle to cope this winter,...

BMA sign

BMA elects new deputy chair of England GP committee and chair of Scottish council

Dr David Wrigley has been elected as new deputy chair of the BMA's GP committee in...

UK money

Almost half of practices say income from private fees has fallen in past year

Almost half of GP practices have seen their income from private and professional...

COVID-19 vaccination centre

BMA raises 'serious concerns' about GP workload and funding for autumn COVID boosters

The BMA has raised 'serious concerns' about the workload implications of this autumn's...


Monkeypox jabs will run out by next week, UKHSA says

The UK is likely to run out of smallpox vaccine stocks which it is using to protect...

NHS sign outside a building

Two Midlands hospitals end partnerships with Babylon

Two NHS trusts have prematurely severed their relationships with digital health provider,...