Pension tax dossier reveals NHS service closures as doctors forced to cut hours

NHS services across the UK are struggling to keep their doors open - with some forced to close - as doctors reduce their working hours to avoid punitive taxes on pensions, a damning report reveals.

NHS workforce shortage (Photo: Universal Images/Getty Images)

Severe medical staff shortages have left some NHS services 'entirely dependent' on doctors working beyond their basic hours, according to a dossier compiled by the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges (AoMRC) that paints a bleak picture of health service capacity ahead of the coming winter.

These services are now 'at risk' as damaging taxes on pensions that can leave doctors paying more than they earn for taking on extra hours have forced many to refuse additional work, the report says.

GPonline reported last week that GPs could face a devastating knock-on impact as a poll found nearly seven in 10 surgeons had reduced their working hours to avoid tax penalties.

NHS services

The AoMRC dossier, sent to health and social care secretary Matt Hancock and chancellor Sajid Javid, brings together evidence showing how doctors across medical specialties have been forced to refuse shifts and cut back on working hours.

Significant reductions in hospital capacity could add to GP workload as patients seek reassurance and additional support while hospital treatment is delayed. BMA GP committee chair Dr Richard Vautrey warned last month that 'longer waits mean GPs will struggle further to help their patients get the timely care they need, and this is likely to impact practice workload'.

In one case highlighted in the report, Guy’s and St Thomas’s hospital in London 'closed an ICU for 18 weeks over the summer', while at Mid Essex Hospital Services Trust staff have warned it may be impossible to keep the high dependency unit open over weekends.

The AoMRC report warns that three quarters of consultant anaesthetists had reduced their workload, while among doctors in emergency medicine a similar proportion were considering this.

Workforce crisis

Three quarters of emergency medicine doctors said patient flow was being adversely affected 'as a result of the taxation issue’s impact on the availability of appropriate medical workforce'.

Among members of the Royal College of Physicians, nearly half planned to retire early - with 86% citing concerns over the pension tax crisis. A drop in workforce among radiologists, paediatricians and doctors in obstetrics and gynaecology was also reported.

In a letter to Mr Hancock and Mr Javid, AoMRC chair Professor Caroline MacEwen says: 'Itis evident from the findings that, due to severe medical staff shortages, the NHS has become entirely dependent on consultants delivering service provision over and above their existing contracts; this service is being put at risk because of the current pension taxation position.

'Furthermore, our findings indicate that pensions taxation is undermining staff morale, which is detrimental to the recruitment and retention of the medical workforce. Staff shortages in the NHS are a significant concern and we must ensure these pressures do not intensify further as a result of the pension arrangements.'

The letter warns that government proposals for additional pension 'flexibility' around contributions to NHS pensions 'are insufficient to tackle the long-term problems'.

GPonline reported last week on a warning from the Association of Independent Specialist Medical Accountants (Aisma) that the government's proposals were no more than 'uninformed tinkering'.

Government tax advisers have suggested that the annual allowance cap on NHS pensions could be removed. Mr Hancock has said that if the Treasury was to take this step the DHSC may scrap plans for pension flexibilities.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

Medical centre sign

GP service charges cut by up to £400,000 in 'groundbreaking' legal case

Six-figure service charge fees that threatened practices' survival have been reduced...

Talking General Practice logo

Podcast: How rising costs are adding to pressure on UK practices, plus has the ARRS met its target?

In our regular news review the team discusses calls for emergency funding to support...

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer

GPs invite Starmer for talks after criticism of partnership model

Senior GPs have urged Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer to meet them for talks to 'shape...

NHS sign

GPs risk being 'left behind' by plan to fix NHS pension discrimination

GPs could be left behind by plans to fix unlawful age discrimination under the NHS...

Woman using a laptop

How virtual training can support GPs to develop their personalised care skills

GP Dr Priti Kadoo explains how the Personalised Care Institute's new 'virtual patient'...

Blood test in a lab

Blood test for multiple cancers can diagnose two-thirds of cases, study suggests

A blood test for more than 50 types of cancer has been found to correctly diagnose...