PCTs deny bariatric surgery to obese patients

Obese patients are being denied potentially life-saving bariatric surgery, as PCT commissioners look to cut costs by rationing the treatment for diabetics.

Current NICE guidance states that bariatric surgery should be offered to all patients with a BMI over 50 as a first line treatment.

Bariatric surgery is considered to be one of the most clinically and cost effective treatments on the NHS.  However, the initial costs of the surgery can reach up to £14,000.

A number of PCTs across England are defying NICE and are offering the surgery only to obese patients who have diabetes or severe sleep apnoea.

Research has shown that gastric banding is effective in achieving remission of type-2 diabetes, and offers huge cost savings to PCTs in terms of reducing diabetes drug budgets.

Bedfordshire, East and North Hertfordshire, Greater Yarmouth and Waveney, Cambridgeshire, Mid and North and South East Essex and Norfolk PCTs are all insisting that obese patients must have diabetes before being considered for surgery, according to an audit conducted by the British Obesity Surgery Patient Association.

East of England specialised commissioning group, which covers these PCTs, confirms on its website that obese patients must have diabetes or severe sleep apnoea, as well as being  aged 18-60.

Dr David Haslam, clinical director of the National Obesity Forum and a GP in Hertfordshire, said: ‘It is a ridiculous situation. If you are obese and diabetic then funding is made available as it is deemed cost effective by the PCT.

‘PCT commissioning groups are putting barriers in the way to prevent patients from receiving what can be life-saving surgery.'


  • Read this week's GP dated 24 July for the full version of this story
  • Is your PCT restricting bariatric surgery?

More news from 22 July

Study finds access to a career in medicine is worsening
Failing foundation trusts to be 'de-authorised' in wake of Mid Staffs scandal
DoH targets national newspapers with swine flu ads
Mixing medicines backed for nurse prescribers

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in