PCN agreements must be watertight or GPs could face claims, lawyers warn

GPs could face disputes and financial claims if legal agreements underpinning primary care networks (PCNs) are not watertight, lawyers have warned.

(Photo: Witthaya Prasongsin/Getty Images)
(Photo: Witthaya Prasongsin/Getty Images)

Speaking to GPonline, lawyer Justin Cumberlege, a partner at Hempsons which has expertise in primary care, described the new network templates as a ‘useful framework’ but highlighted the importance of thoroughness when drawing up legal agreements between practices.

‘There are lots of variables to consider, and it will not be one size fits all,’ Mr Cumberlege said. ‘As a legally binding contract, skimping over the detail could lead to misunderstandings, and at worst disputes and claims in the future.’

He encouraged GP partners to reduce the risk of individual liability by ensuring ‘all partners’ involved in a network are signed up to a contract that ‘binds the partnership’.

Primary care networks

Practices have been asked to ‘complete and return’ their PCN registration - which involves identifying a list of ‘proposed member GP practices’ with whom they plan to form a network - by 15 May 2019, in order to sign up to the network contract DES.

Once the proposed networks have been approved by local CCGs, every practice within a PCN will have to sign the network agreement, completing the registration process by 30 June 2019. The agreement consists of a mandatory set of clauses, which cannot be changed, and a set of schedules, where practices can set out the specific arrangements of their network.

Getting detailed agreements in place may prove particularly difficult for practices that have not previously been involved in forming a GP alliance or similar organisation, Mr Cumberlege said, as ‘they may not know where to start, or may miss important information out’.

DES payments

According to documents published by NHS England, each network must identify a ‘single practice or provider’ to receive funding on behalf of the whole PCN by 15 May.

Deciding who has control of the network's payments and how they are distributed could be ‘particularly contentious’, Mr Cumberlege said, adding that the sharing of staff should also be ‘meticulously thought through’ with attention being paid to ‘potential VAT charges as well as employment issues’.

The provision of healthcare services is exempt from VAT, but providing healthcare or back-office staff is not. Therefore if practices set up a network structure that involves employing staff in a separate organisation they may find that they are liable to pay VAT on the provision of staff to constituent practices.

Practices should also bear in mind the possibility ‘for the agreements to extend to other organisations in the future’ when forming networks, as this would give the PCN ‘an advantage’, Mr Cumberlege said.

A recent FAQ document published by NHS England at the start of April revealed that PCNs will be expected to have a 'wide-reaching membership' in future that could involve other local providers such as local pharmacy, optometrists, dental providers and social care providers. There is no requirement in the 2019/20 DES for any collaboration between practices and other providers to be documented in their network agreement, but NHS England guidance suggests that networks could include this if such relationships already exist.

'Clear legal agreement'

Overall, Mr Cumberlege said he was ‘quite pleased’ with the way the network agreement template had been structured, because it gave practices the flexibility to shape their legal arrangements to suit their circumstances. 'It’s really for them to think about the details, about what is going to work for them,' he said.

GPC chair Dr Richard Vautrey told GPonline: ‘The templates and supporting information have been produced to provide a good starting point for each developing PCN. It is though important, as with any working relationship such as a practice partnership agreement, to have a clear legal agreement that can be called upon if necessary when decisions are being made. PCNs will all have differences and choose different ways of working, so any network agreement needs to properly reflect that.’

Hempsons say they have already received a ‘number of enquiries’ from practices looking for advice on forming networks.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

GP at Hand should only be allowed to provide NHS 111 services, says BMA

GP at Hand should only be allowed to provide NHS 111 services, says BMA

Babylon GP at Hand should no longer be allowed to register patients and instead be...

A financial guide for GP locums

A financial guide for GP locums

Medical accountant Jenny Stone provides a guide to pensions, setting your fees and...

Paying tax as a GP locum

Paying tax as a GP locum

Medical accountant Jenny Stone explains how you pay your tax as a GP locum.

DNA testing could be part of NHS health checks under government plans

DNA testing could be part of NHS health checks under government plans

The DHSC has launched a review of NHS health checks, with a view to introducing a...

Most GPs now see locum work as most attractive career option, poll reveals

Most GPs now see locum work as most attractive career option, poll reveals

More than half of GPs now believe locum work is the most attractive career option...

Patients in deprived areas find it harder to get GP appointments

Patients in deprived areas find it harder to get GP appointments

Three out of five people living in the most deprived areas in England find it difficult...