Patients want GPs arguing for hospital closures to quantify benefits

Patients trust GPs who argue why hospital services should close to improve care but want potential benefits to be quantified so success can be judged, according to a leading GP.

‘If you shave a ward off every hospital, you’ll save very little. We are going to have to close hospitals.’
‘If you shave a ward off every hospital, you’ll save very little. We are going to have to close hospitals.’

‘The public generally do trust you because you are a doctor,’ Dr Johnny Marshall, a member of the National Association of Primary Care’s executive told a meeting of the Westminster Health Forum in central London about commissioning on Wednesday.

‘But they want you to be able to quantify, perhaps in terms of 10 or 20 lives saved a year, what would be the consequences of certain actions. In that way they can measure how successful you were.’

Dr Marshall was speaking about the need for openness and public involvement when difficult rationing or decommissioning decisions had to be made. Money could often be saved by reducing secondary care services and pushing work into the community, closer to patients, which is popular with them.

He added: ‘The crucial part of the whole process is that you can’t keep commissioning new things. You also have to stop doing things that don’t have the same level of value. It’s really important to explain outcomes to the population so you’re not just creating fear by removing facilities.

‘If you shave a ward off every hospital, you’ll save very little. We are going to have to close hospitals.’

Gary Belfield, associate partner at consultants KPMG, said up to 30% of patients in hospitals could safely be seen in ‘lower-value settings’, which could provide opportunities for third sector involvement.

* Read our Inside Commissioning blog for the latest thinking on redesigning healthcare

GP magazine is a media partner for Commissioning 2012, an event in London on 27-28 June featuring over 700 GPs and primary care managers. Speakers are expected to include health secretary Andrew Lansley and NHS chief executive Sir David Nicholson.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Viewpoint: 'Why the RCGP should not adopt a neutral stance on assisted dying'

Viewpoint: 'Why the RCGP should not adopt a neutral stance on assisted dying'

The RCGP is currently surveying members for their views on assisted dying. In response...

Hurried GP consultations 'a scandal', RCGP chair warns

Hurried GP consultations 'a scandal', RCGP chair warns

Hurried consultations in general practice are 'a scandal that needs to be named'...

GMC labels overseas GP registration 'unfit for purpose' as British doctor denied work

GMC labels overseas GP registration 'unfit for purpose' as British doctor denied work

The GMC has labelled the system for registering overseas doctors as 'unfit for purpose'...

Which parts of England are facing a GP retirement timebomb?

Which parts of England are facing a GP retirement timebomb?

In parts of England more than 40% of the GP workforce in permanent roles is aged...

GPs need rapid access to cancer tests to speed up diagnosis, says RCGP

GPs need rapid access to cancer tests to speed up diagnosis, says RCGP

GPs need better access to cancer tests, the RCGP has warned, after research showed...

GP training: How to get the most from the trainee e-portfolio

GP training: How to get the most from the trainee e-portfolio

Dr Patrice Baptiste provides advice on what GP trainees need to include in their...