Out-of-hours providers should benchmark GPs

Foundation report calls for GPs to be compared on performance and productivity.

Dr Fay Wilson: 'We find it useful. If we find it useful, other people might' (Photograph: J Heath Lancy)
Dr Fay Wilson: 'We find it useful. If we find it useful, other people might' (Photograph: J Heath Lancy)

Out-of-hours providers should benchmark individual GPs' performance and productivity against their peers, the Primary Care Foundation has said.

Giving individuals breakdowns of their performance and productivity would help iron out differences in services and improvement performance over all, it believes.

The foundation analysed data from 96 out-of-hours services across England.

It found that demand on services was consistent and predictable and that a small number of services perform consistently well. Other services fall short of meeting quality standards and consistently prioritising cases.

In a report published last week, the foundation argued that variations in the performance of different members of staff was likely to be an important cause of such failings.

'The variation between clinical staff is not closely managed, so that the service performs well when some staff are on duty and less well when others are working,' the report said.

'Because clinicians want to do a good job, they value comparison with their peers,' it added.

'We strongly support the initiative by some software providers to make it much easier for services to feedback productivity information (from a large sample of cases) to individual clinicians (as part of a rounded audit process that also looks in detail at a smaller sample of cases).'

The BADGER out-of-hours co-operative in Birmingham already runs a similar benchmarking scheme, Dr Fay Wilson, chairwoman of the scheme, said.

Its scheme sends quarterly breakdowns of performance, giving each GP details of their performance and comparing it with the average across the co-operative.

Dr Wilson said that such benchmarking helped her look at outliers on particular measures and reassured her about performance across the co- operative.

'We find it useful,' Dr Wilson said. 'If we find it useful, other people might.'

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Shielded patients and care home residents to receive free vitamin D

Shielded patients and care home residents to receive free vitamin D

Patients on the shielding list and care homes are to be provided with free vitamin...

LMCs demand renegotiation of COVID-19 enhanced service deal

LMCs demand renegotiation of COVID-19 enhanced service deal

LMCs have called for a renegotiation of funding for the COVID-19 vaccination enhanced...

LMCs demand ballot of profession on PCN DES ahead of next contract talks

LMCs demand ballot of profession on PCN DES ahead of next contract talks

LMCs have demanded a ballot of GPs on the primary care network (PCN) DES before BMA...

Lack of support left locums at physical and financial risk in pandemic, say LMCs

Lack of support left locums at physical and financial risk in pandemic, say LMCs

Locum GPs have faced significant physical and financial risk because of a lack of...

LMCs demand NHS England apology over ‘abhorrent' claims about general practice

LMCs demand NHS England apology over ‘abhorrent' claims about general practice

LMCs have called on NHS England to apologise for ‘abhorrent and insulting’ suggestions...

CCGs to be stripped of commissioning role under reforms backed by NHS England

CCGs to be stripped of commissioning role under reforms backed by NHS England

CCGs could be stripped of their commissioning role under plans set out by NHS England,...