NHS panel defines rules for rationing decisions

Cataract surgery, knee replacement and other 'low clinical value' treatments must only be restricted on the basis of strict evidence-based criteria, an NHS panel has warned.

Treatments such as knee replacement surgery should only be restricted on evidence-based criteria (Photograph: SPL)
Treatments such as knee replacement surgery should only be restricted on evidence-based criteria (Photograph: SPL)

Inconsistency in access to 'low clinical value' treatments leads to postcode lotteries, the Quality, Innovation, Productivity and Prevention Right Care Team said.

Last year, GP revealed that most PCTs now have lists restricting 'non-urgent' or 'low clinical value' treatments, such as knee replacement and cataract and bariatric surgery.

The Right Care Team was commissioned by NHS medical director Professor Sir Bruce Keogh to determine how the clinical value of such treatments should be decided.

The team has now issued its 'emerging views' to NHS officials, arguing that blanket bans should be abandoned.

'We propose that the NHS Commissioning Board support the development of "value -based clinical commissioning guidance" for elective surgical care pathways through a partnership between the surgical speciality associations and NICE,' the team said.

The report sets out the key issues to be addressed in assessing the clinical value and demand for treatments.

For cataract surgery, the quality of decisions early in the referral process needs to be improved and demand balanced against NHS capacity.

For bariatric operations, the need to 'change perception' about the need for surgery is identified as a 'key issue'.

The team will develop guidance for commissioners based on these principles.

GPC deputy chairman Dr Richard Vautrey said the guidance must be transparent and implemented consistently, without local areas applying additional restrictions.

All the 'difficult discussions' about rationing needed to be led by politicians, and to be carried out openly 'with patients as partners', he said.

'We need more discussions with patients in the public arena about what the NHS can pay for and what it is inappropriate for it to pay for,' he said. Dr Vautrey added that explicit rationing needed to be carried out equitably.

'Patients will accept it, if they think it is fair and not discriminating against particular groups of patients,' he said.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

External wall of GP surgery with wording 'medical centre'

‘Utterly toxic’: GPs speak out over abuse and physical attacks on practice teams

GPs have condemned a rise in verbal and physical attacks on practice staff - warning...

Artist's image of a spiked virus

Javid warns of 'substantial risk' from new COVID-19 variant

The highly mutated COVID-19 variant B.1.1.529 'may pose a significant risk to public...

Desk with lettering 'LMC conference'

LMCs reject 'outdated' GMS contract and demand move to item of service payments

LMCs have voted to scrap the 'outdated and inadequate' GMS contract and to replace...

GPs at an LMC conference waving green voting cards in the air

LMCs demand ringfence on enhanced services cash and clear GP representation in ICSs

LMCs have called for a ringfence on enhanced services funding, along with a guarantee...

Close up of hands typing on a computer

Practices should not be required to provide online consultations, say LMCs

Online consultations should no longer be a part of the GMS contract and targets for...

Sign outside BMA House

More than half of GP practices prepared to pull out of PCNs, BMA ballot shows

More than half of GP practices in England are prepared to opt out of the PCN DES...