'Mega-PCNs' could struggle to have frontline impact, warns top GP

Primary care networks (PCNs) with patient lists of more than 80,000 may struggle to address health challenges specific to their communities, a senior GP who helped develop the model has warned.

Dr Nav Chana
Dr Nav Chana

Former National Association of Primary Care (NAPC) chair Dr Nav Chana said ‘mega-PCNs’ - networks that drastically exceed the typical population size of 30,000-50,000 - could find it difficult to deliver personalised care and integrate services if they did not carefully consider the effects of scaling up their operations.

NHS England has confirmed that nearly one in 10 of the 1,259 PCNs that went live across England from 1 July were smaller than the lower end of the expected patient list size. It has not published figures on the number of PCNs that exceed the upper end of the scale, although it confirmed in June that there would be ‘a significant number’ of PCNs with patients lists greater than 50,000.

However, data published on CCG websites reveal that some PCNs cover double or more than double the assumed maximum patient list size. One PCN in east Cornwall covers 105,395 patients, and another in Darlington has around 108,625 patients.

Primary care networks

Vale of York CCG lists a PCN with almost 150,000 patients - three times the size of a typically large network. 

Speaking to GPonline, Dr Chana, who helped develop and roll out of more than 200 primary care home (PCH) sites across England, the model on which the PCN model is largely based, said: ‘Of course it’s possible that PCNs larger than 50,000 patients can still provide personalised care, we’ve got some examples of how that can be done.

‘But if the next step is to say, well actually, let’s increase to 80,000 patients or let’s round up to 100,000 then, actually, I think there’s a danger of creating more of an organisation rather than a community-facing integration-type approach. And, that’s because you need to create some bureaucracy within that to build relationships between people.

‘We’ve had examples of going too large in the past four or five year and, in some situations that’s worked. But in other situations it hasn’t.'

Neighbourhood approach

Dr Chana cited the recent approach adopted by Modality, a GP super-partnership of more than 400,000 people, and how it had managed to create a 'neighbourhood-type approach' despite its size. Following a study, the partnership found it could improve continuity of care and reduce GP workload by 'chunking' its patient list into smaller groups.

‘If we are genuinely going to join up care around people with complex needs and some of the challenges that we face in communities, we need to have a different model than just lumping something into one big organisational infrastructure.

‘So, [if networks choose to have larger population sizes], I think [they] need to keep the benefits of working small, as well as getting the benefits of working as large organisations.’

The key to PCNs benefiting communities, Dr Chana stressed, was not necessarily down to their size but how networks adapted their approaches according to serve their communities.

Population health

‘With a population of 30,000 you can start to do much more around population health management and creating an integrated workforce, and starting to collectively manage things, getting benefits from an economy of scale. This is also without losing the intimacy of what people and patients want and the sense of belonging that the workforce has.

‘But there are also greater things you can do on a bigger scale, say a federation scale, those things to having economies of scale and maybe taking on some of the contractual issues and HR and organisational development issues.'

Dr Chana advised larger PCNs to look at how they could retain elements of smaller-scale networks. ‘I think all I would say is just work out what you need to do at what level. Because there’s something that may happen at 50,000 may be great, but actually there might be some challenges around how you design particular workforce approaches around smaller populations, so what’s the way in which you can get the benefit of both.

‘Quite a lot of examples, some of the larger primary care organisations have created sort of smaller front-end delivery units which are focused on integrating workforce and that level and retaining the benefit of the scale behind it.'

A spokesperson for NHS England, said: 'Local primary care networks determine their own size based on what they know will work best for their patients, while the NHS is backing family doctors with an extra £4.5billion in primary and community care and recruiting 20,000 more pharmacists, physios and paramedics across primary care networks to free up GPs to spend more time with their sickest patients.'

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Why a popular GP practice is resisting calls to join a PCN

Why a popular GP practice is resisting calls to join a PCN

GPs at a small, exceptionally popular GP practice in Northumberland are among only...

Swollen calf - red flag symptoms

Swollen calf - red flag symptoms

Refresh your knowledge of red flag symptoms to look out for in presentations of swollen...

How to ensure safe online prescribing

How to ensure safe online prescribing

As more patients begin to access GP services online, prescribing online is becoming...

NHS to pay doctors' pension tax in bid to end workforce crisis ahead of winter

NHS to pay doctors' pension tax in bid to end workforce crisis ahead of winter

The NHS could be set to pay doctors' pension tax bills in a move the BMA says could...

Scottish government unveils plan to ease pension tax crisis as BMA urges UK-wide action

Scottish government unveils plan to ease pension tax crisis as BMA urges UK-wide action

The Scottish government has unveiled plans to divert employer pension contributions...

Huge variation in time and money for GP-based teaching in medical schools

Huge variation in time and money for GP-based teaching in medical schools

UK medical schools are allocating vastly different amounts of time and money to GP-focused...