Matrons do not cut hospital admissions

Community matrons as ‘case managers' do not improve rates of emergency admissions or mortality for the over-65s, findings from the Evercare pilot scheme suggest.

Focusing on patients with at least two emergency admissions in the previous year, compared with patients at control practices, those from the Evercare scheme were 2.5 per cent more likely to have emergency admissions, and had a 5.5 per cent increased risk of mortality.  

However, they spent less time in hospital, with a 4.9 per cent reduction in emergency bed days.  

Hospital episode statistics for 62 practices in England using Evercare between June 2003 and March 2005 were compared with those for around 7,000 control practices. The pilots pre-empt the introduction of nurse-led case management in England, with 3,000 community matrons due to be in place by 2007.  

Case management was popular among patients, but experts said the cost of community matrons cannot be justified if there was no improvement to health.  

The findings could undermine some practice-based commissioning schemes which intended to save money by cutting hospital admissions using community matrons (GP, 17 February).  

Lead researcher Professor Martin Roland, director of the National Primary Care Research and Development Centre at Manchester, said: ‘It was never likely that this would make an impact on admissions, and it’s not going to save money.’  

Dr Andrew Dearden, chairman of the GPC community care committee, said: ‘What this seems to show is that patients like it because there’s someone there to talk to, which is a benefit for patients, but it doesn’t benefit patient health.  

‘Does the DoH want to improve people’s health or do they want people to feel emo-tionally better?’ 

Evercare outcomes

Emergency admissions
UP 2.5%

Mortality
UP 5.5%

Emergency bed days
DOWN 4.9% 

 

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Proportion of NHS GPs trained in EEA stabilises despite Brexit uncertainty

Proportion of NHS GPs trained in EEA stabilises despite Brexit uncertainty

The proportion of NHS GPs trained in the EEA has stabilised after a steady decline...

GPs split on calls to suspend appraisal for duration of pandemic

GPs split on calls to suspend appraisal for duration of pandemic

Senior GPs are divided over calls for appraisal to be halted for the rest of the...

GP fears rising over covert recording of consultations in pandemic

GP fears rising over covert recording of consultations in pandemic

Fears over patients covertly recording consultations have increased among GPs since...

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

GPonline provides an overview of the key guidance relating to coronavirus, including...

Care home vaccination to begin as Scottish minister says Pfizer vaccine packs can be split up

Care home vaccination to begin as Scottish minister says Pfizer vaccine packs can be split up

Vaccination of care home residents against COVID-19 will start on 14 December in...

How will the COVID-19 vaccination programme get underway?

How will the COVID-19 vaccination programme get underway?

Following the MHRA's approval of Pfizer/BioNTech's COVID-19 jab the government has...