The 2006 National Trainee Survey, jointly undertaken by the Postgraduate Medical Education and Training Board (PMETB) and Conference of Postgraduate Medical Deans (COPMeD), analysed responses from nearly 25,000 trainees. The survey, designed to drive improvements in postgraduate medical education, has found that the majority of trainees are satisfied with the training they receive but identified variations in experience. Initial results were published in November last year.
The survey consistently points to a link between better supervision during training and greater satisfaction with training posts.
Higher supervision, higher satisfaction
The survey reveals that GP trainees rated the quality of their supervision more highly than any other specialty group, scoring it at 90/100. This was reflected with them scoring 80/100 for satisfaction with their posts overall. Trainee surgeon Senior House Officers (SHOs) scored the quality of their supervision the lowest of all groups (around 65/100) and this is again reflected by the fact that they rated themselves the least satisfied with their posts (although still scoring around 75 out of 100).
Importantly, the survey also links better supervision with the perceived incidence of bullying: GP trainees indicate the lowest exposure to bullying with around 6% experiencing this behaviour. Around 14% of the surgery SHOs experienced perceived bullying but they were not the highest. Around 16% of obstetrics and gynaecology trainees - with the second lowest supervision score - topped the table of those specialty groups reporting perceived bullying. The survey measured the incidence of bullying by asking trainees if they had been subjected to persistent behaviour in their posts that had undermined their professional confidence and/or self esteem.
Driving up improvement
Postgraduate deaneries across the UK (which oversee delivery of training) have used the survey's findings to develop action plans to ensure that possible weaknesses identified by trainees are addressed. A summary of the action plans is also published as part of the report.
Anita Thomas, Chair of the PMETB Training Committee, said: "PMETB's goal is to ensure that UK postgraduate medical education and training is of the highest quality. This survey shows that most trainees see the training they receive as satisfactory but also that improvements can be made. Medical students and Foundation Years doctors work phenomenally hard to gain access to specialist training and have every right to expect the highest standards when they are in training - including a working environment free from bullying. To put it simply, the survey suggests that trainees feel that the more supported they are, the more they get from their training and the better prepared they are to contribute towards good patient care."
Professor Elisabeth Paice, Chair of COPMeD said: "Understanding where training could be better is a fundamental step in helping deaneries to deliver improvements. The National Trainee Survey gives trainees a powerful voice in ensuing that their training equips them to deliver the highest standards of care to patients. It is the deaneries' challenge to ensure that trainees' dedication is repaid by making sure that their training is the best - and most supportive - it can be."
Next steps will be the 2007 National Trainee Survey, which will also compare trainees' perceptions with the views of those who train them. The full National Trainee Survey report, and further details on the survey, can be downloaded from www.pmetb.org.uk/traineesurvey