Limits on GP minor surgery cost £57m

Exclusive: Restrictions on GP minor surgery have cut practice income by up to £32,400 a year, damaged the profession's skill base and wasted millions of pounds, the RCGP has said.

Minor surgery: RCGP to build evidence for GP-led interventions (photo: SPL)
Minor surgery: RCGP to build evidence for GP-led interventions (photo: SPL)

Unfair rules imposed by commissioners and NICE have 'destroyed' the ability of practices to offer skin cancer surgery, according to RCGP minor surgery clinical champion Dr Jonathan Botting.

Many skilled primary care surgeons have 'given up' providing services and 'disenfranchised' GPs are now reluctant to train, he said.

Patients are now referred to hospitals for treatment costing up to 19 times as much as GP services. Dr Botting criticised NICE's skin cancer guidance for putting a 'massive rift' between primary and secondary care over minor surgery.

He said its 2006 skin cancer guidance blocked the ability of GPs to remove malignant melanomas or carcinomas. Updated guidance issued in 2010 continues to restrict surgical activity, he added.

'Phenomenal' NHS savings would be possible if primary care was allowed to offer more procedures, he said.

'Many GPs can perform a wide range of minor surgery,' he said. 'However, many patients are referred to secondary care at a considerable cost to the NHS.'

A skin cancer procedure costs from £378 to £1,612 in hospital settings – compared with £87 through the primary care DES tariff. Treating all melanomas and half of non-melanoma skin cancers in primary care could save the NHS at least £57m a year (see graphic).

A practice performing nine skin cancer excisions a week could earn up to £32,400 a year. But 'virtually no' such work is now undertaken in primary care, he said.

Dr Paul Charlson, a Yorkshire GPSI in dermatology, said: 'If GPs are taking basal cell carcinomas (BCCs) off people's bodies and we have margin rates as good as anyone else, then why not? I don't know why there is a restriction.'

He agreed NICE guidance stopped 'some very good GP surgeons' operating on skin cancers and 'put people off' training.

Primary care surgeons were vital because dermatology services are 'swamped', he added.

The RCGP launched an audit this month to prove GP minor surgery is as safe and effective as procedures carried out in secondary care.

GPC deputy chairman Dr Richard Vautrey backed the audit and said skilled GPs were being prevented from using their training.

A NICE spokeswoman said the 2010 guidance clarified when GPs can remove low-risk BCCs.

This advised how services can be commissioned 'to ensure that the most appropriate healthcare professional treats each BCC'.

GP expert view

Dr Brian Malcolm, associate specialist and GPSI in dermatology in Devon

Previously, GPs could do anything in skin surgery. That’s no longer defensible, medicolegally. That’s where we were prior to NICE guidance, and we can't go back there.

But the pendulum has swung far too far. We've gone from everything to nothing.

The ideal situation is that a smaller number of GPs become more specialised, so they can then offer surgery under the guidance. That’s where the common sense feeling is among primary and secondary care. There's far too much work to go around, and it's inappropriate to do it all in secondary care.

Cancer is emotive work. There has to be some accreditation work done, partly for GPs to cut things out, but also on whether it needs to be done: the best surgeon knows when not to operate.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

First COVID-19 jabs to target care home residents and staff under new JCVI advice

First COVID-19 jabs to target care home residents and staff under new JCVI advice

Older adults living in care homes and staff working there will be first to receive...

GPs unable to veto virtual fitness to practise hearings during pandemic

GPs unable to veto virtual fitness to practise hearings during pandemic

GPs facing fitness to practise investigations during the COVID-19 pandemic will be...

Government rejects major NHSPS overhaul - but changes 'could ease GP service charge disputes'

Government rejects major NHSPS overhaul - but changes 'could ease GP service charge disputes'

A government review has rejected calls for a major overhaul of an NHS Property Services...

RCGP urges GPs to collaborate with pharmacies on flu jabs this year

RCGP urges GPs to collaborate with pharmacies on flu jabs this year

The RCGP and the Royal Pharmaceutical Society have called on GP practices and community...

GP appointments rising fast as COVID-19 cases 'near 10,000 a day'

GP appointments rising fast as COVID-19 cases 'near 10,000 a day'

GP appointments have risen rapidly in recent weeks as schools returned, according...

COVID-19 impact on medical schools risks 'serious damage' to future NHS workforce

COVID-19 impact on medical schools risks 'serious damage' to future NHS workforce

Medical training and the future NHS workforce could be seriously damaged by the financial...