Liam Farrell: Reflex response of no great value

In one of the Marx Brothers' movies - I forget which - Groucho is accidentally jostled by a lady.

'Excuse me,' she says politely.

'Why, what'd you do?' he fires back.

I saw this when I was young, and thought it to be the height of droll repartee. I am also very impressionable, so ever since, when anyone says 'Excuse me', I offer Groucho's reply.

However, I don't have the great man's comic timing, nor his disarming cheek, so I usually just sound rude and offensive. But, despite having earned a few thumps over the years, I cannot help myself; it has become a learned reflex, impossible to suppress.

It is curiously similar to another learned reflex of mine, which I suspect many of my colleagues share.

I cannot say 'FBC' without immediately following up with 'U&E'; the words simply trip off my tongue.

The U&E is not usually relevant, but I keep on ordering it just the same. I didn't understand electrolytes in college and I never will. Sodium comes in and potassium goes out, and then, apparently on a whim, potassium comes in and sodium goes out; the Loop of Henle was a veritable jamboree of incomprehensible and capricious ionic migrations.

I suspected the textbooks were making it up as they went along.

The only thing I remember actually understanding was that persistent vomiting may lead to a hypochloremic alkalosis. This little gem has, unfortunately, proved to be of no benefit in real life; when someone is vomiting I am usually more keen on keeping the puke off my shoes than correcting an errant acid-base balance.

Not that FBCs are much more helpful; let's be honest, a common rationale for ordering blood tests is to kick for touch. It keeps the patient happy and gives the feeling that Something Is Being Done; it buys us a little time until they get better on their own.

And all the little add-ons, are they really necessary? In all my years of practice I cannot recall many times when they were of any use in reaching a clinical decision. Memo to the NHS tsars; stop measuring red blood cell distribution width, platelet distribution width and basophil counts, save millions.

It will be tough, but we'll manage without them somehow.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us: