Letters: Skill mix and the benefit of a salaried profession

I was interested in the article 'Job crisis is "bigger threat" than private firms' (GP, 21 November). The job crisis is, indeed, worse than the threat of private firms.

I moved six years ago from Bristol, where I was a partner, expecting to get a partnership after some struggle - some struggle it has been.

Certainly, this crisis isn't confined to younger GPs. There is a sizeable minority of middle-aged, experienced GPs who cannot get into partnerships.

The reason? Mostly partners and partly the government.

What has happened is that there is a growing underclass of non-principal GPs and practice nurses who bolster the falling wages of partners.

Of the few partnerships that come up locally, most are filled in-house or by word of mouth. Very few are advertised.

Partners see that it's more work-efficient and cost-efficient to employ nurse practitioners and non-principals but I wonder whether they have thought through the consequences for many highly trained, motivated non-principals?

At the moment there is a surprising lack of debate or complaint about this issue.

But it suits the government too - it must be aiming to usher in a new salaried profession. Again, there is no debate about this: when sufficient numbers of us non-principals exist, the logic for a salaried profession will too.

But it's odd that none of us GPs are talking about the possible benefits. No mention is made of the fact that hospital doctors manage in a salaried role without their integrity being compromised.

We could be freed from the business aspect of general practice for which there is no training in medical school and which detracts from patient care.

We could be more honest as a profession - few patients realise that GP surgeries are run as businesses for the profit of the partners. Maybe that's why GP principals are kicking up a fuss?

At 48, I've just managed to get another salaried post locally. I'm not bitter - I'm sure I would have behaved similarly to most principals. But I am perturbed that the truth is not reaching the light of day and perplexed that so few of us are commenting on this worrying trend.

I shouldn't be bitter, it was essentially my fault that I couldn't get a partnership, market forces operated so I should improve my saleability and, what do you expect living in Gloucestershire?

Dr Hugh van't Hoff, Dursley, Gloucestershire.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

GP careers: My life working as a remote GP

GP careers: My life working as a remote GP

Dr Patrice Baptiste explains a typical day in her role as a remote GP and the advantages...

Average GP practice could face £15,000 hit from national insurance hike

Average GP practice could face £15,000 hit from national insurance hike

An average GP practice could face a financial hit of around £15,000 from the national...

Practices could follow suit as hospitals relax infection control over care backlog

Practices could follow suit as hospitals relax infection control over care backlog

Health secretary Sajid Javid has backed a significant relaxation of infection control...

BMA demands priority access for key workers as fuel shortage threatens NHS care

BMA demands priority access for key workers as fuel shortage threatens NHS care

Healthcare workers must be offered priority access to fuel to guarantee that vital...

GPs unable to get to work as petrol shortages hit NHS workforce

GPs unable to get to work as petrol shortages hit NHS workforce

GPs have warned that practice staff are struggling to get to work and are being forced...

Javid must offer 'clear public backing for GPs', warns BMA

Javid must offer 'clear public backing for GPs', warns BMA

The BMA has demanded 'clear public backing' for general practice from the government...