Letters, calls and emails: Clinical acumen, not forms, must diagnose depression

Dear Editor

Dr Liam Farrell’s column inspired me to put my own thoughts on depression down on paper (GP, 22 September).  

This morning I saw three people with depression. One had been suspended from work because of a problem with a manager; one had neighbours from hell and was going to court over it; and one had just been evicted from his home by the mother of his children.  

All three came to see me for something to stop them feeling tearful, anxious, scared and tired. They wanted help. In truth I was the least able person to provide it. All I could offer was palliative care, anxiolytics and antidepressants. The cure for their condition lay in the situation in which they lived.  

Were they ill or were they adjusting to a changing set of social circumstances?  

I admit to not asking any of them to complete a depression score questionnaire. I did not offer them unavailable services such as counselling or CBT. Instead I gave them what little time I had. In the new NHS I would be seen as a ‘bad’ doctor.  

My Collins dictionary describes depression as feelings of gloom and inadequacy. As such, it could be described as a normal state of mind, in that the majority of the population will have such feelings at some time in their lives. If it is so prevalent, can it be genuinely called a medical illness? Are we not medicalising yet another common condition, as we have done with obesity, shyness, erectile dysfunction or ADHD? Such categorisation depends on severity.  

The problem with mental illness is that it cannot be easily quantified. Attempts to do so with questionnaires are debatably validated and tend to be all encompassing. Any individual’s score might oscillate from one end of the spectrum to the other within a day.  

Ultimately, diagnosis is one of the few clinical skills left to the experience and understanding of the clinician.  

GPs, as individuals, pour scorn on such questionnaires yet as a group we meekly accept them as part of the latest quality framework provisions. One cannot measure emotions and yet we have ‘clinical’ targets whose attainment is worth 48 points. We deride the DoH for setting goals irrelevant to patient care but forget that it only acts on the advice of healthcare professionals. It does not pluck subjects like chronic kidney disease or depression out of thin air.  

Who is it that advises the bureaucrats and why are they not accountable to the rest of us who have to implement their ridiculous suggestions?  

Dr Jim Sherifi  

Colchester, Essex 

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

BMA GP chair: 'GPs let down by tone deaf NHS demands on face-to-face appointments'

BMA GP chair: 'GPs let down by tone deaf NHS demands on face-to-face appointments'

NHS England has let down general practice with its 'tone deaf' demand for all patients...

GPs told to offer face-to-face appointments for all patients

GPs told to offer face-to-face appointments for all patients

GPs have condemned a 'blanket' demand from NHS England that all patients should be...

GP federation network seeks to boost primary care representation amid NHS reforms

GP federation network seeks to boost primary care representation amid NHS reforms

The NHS Confederation has set up a national network for GP federations in a bid to...

Sharp rise in GPs seeking mental health support during past year

Sharp rise in GPs seeking mental health support during past year

The number of GPs seeking help from NHS Practitioner Health, the specialist service...

Podcast: The GP workload crisis, mental wellbeing and vaccination success

Podcast: The GP workload crisis, mental wellbeing and vaccination success

In this episode of our new podcast Talking General Practice we look at the GP workload...

Long wait for COVID-19 public inquiry 'could drive doctors to quit NHS'

Long wait for COVID-19 public inquiry 'could drive doctors to quit NHS'

Doctors' leaders have criticised government plans to delay a public inquiry into...