Legal bid seeks right for GPs to offer private services to their NHS patients

A practice has begun a legal challenge against GMS contract rules that stop practices offering private services to patients on their own list, arguing that the move could help GPs avoid 'going under'.

GP consultation (Photo:
GP consultation (Photo:

The New Forest Central Medical Group has instructed solicitors to take the first steps in challenging part 19 of the standard GMS (and its PMS equivalent) contract, which currently prevents GPs from charging patients for all but a handful of services, such as travel vaccines.

The challenge could put GPs in the same position as NHS consultants, dentists or pharmacists - who can charge their NHS patients for treatments over and above those provided by the health service.

Although GPs are currently allowed to offer services privately, they are not allowed to do so to patients that are on their registered practice list - meaning patients must be sent elsewhere for treatments such as private vaccinations or cosmetic procedures.

GMS contract

The GPC has voiced support for the challenge, saying it has been seeking a change in the GMS contract ‘for some time’.

New Forest GP Dr Matthew Davies, who is also a qualified lawyer, said he had begun the challenge because general practice could 'go under' unless it can ‘diversify its funding' in this way.

He said that successfully challenging the GMS contract would ‘enable [GPs] to offer private services over and above those offered by the NHS to our own patients, increasing patient choice and also increasing practice funding so as to subsidise NHS provision of general practice'.

BMA Law - a law firm set up by the union to offer expert medical advice to doctors - has taken on the case. Four key arguments include questions around whether GPs should be allowed to operate privately outside of core hours and whether - especially in rural areas - restrictions on additional GP services could be classed as a ‘restraint of trade’.


To cover legal fees, Dr Davies has set up a crowdfunding page which has raised £3,400 of a £5,000 target in just a matter of days.

GPC chair Dr Richard Vautrey said: ‘We believe that GPs should be able to provide minor treatments and procedures that are not available through the NHS and therefore reducing the need for patients to seek expensive private hospital procedures. It would be reasonable to expect that patients would want to be able to get this service from their practice, from GPs they know, rather than having to be referred elsewhere.

‘Any change must not compromise the care available to all patients, free at the point of delivery within the NHS contract.'

Last year, GPs rejected a call for a ‘private, alternative model’ of general practice at the England LMC’s conference following a rare intervention from the RCGP. Speaking ahead of the debate in 2017, RCGP chair Professor Helen Stokes-Lampard warned that, despite immense pressures, ‘privatisation of general practice in any shape or form is not the answer’.

However, Dr Davies said his practice had been offered ‘a lot of support’ through messages of encouragement and financial contributions to the crowdfunding site.

‘Obviously it will be a contentious issue and not for everyone and I fully respect those views, but we felt something needed to be done. At least we will have asked those important questions,’ he said.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Rebuild GP campaign logo

Hundreds of GPs sign open letter highlighting 'decades of neglect' of general practice

Hundreds of GPs have signed an open letter to patients warning that 'decades of neglect'...

Dr Farah Jameel

PCNs are 'existential threat' to GP independent contractor model, BMA warns

The BMA's England GP committee has warned that PCNs pose an 'existential threat'...

Houses of Parliament

GP partnerships 'like collapsing Jenga stack' after Javid threat to nationalise practices

Sajid Javid's decision to back a report calling for the end of the GMS contract within...

£20 notes spread out

VAT trap for PCNs could strip millions of pounds from general practice

Tens of millions of pounds could be stripped from general practice because work carried...

Talking General Practice logo

Podcast: Is the BMA representing GPs effectively, why GPs face a pension tax hit, and views on the workload crisis

In our regular news review the team discusses representation of GPs, a new survey...

Man sleeping

NICE guidance on insomnia backs app to replace sleeping pills

Hundreds of thousands of people with insomnia could be offered treatment via a mobile...