Lansley pledges to investigate PCT rationing

Health secretary Andrew Lansley has pledged to investigate evidence of PCTs rationing services after the issue was raised again in parliamentary questions.

Labour MPs presented Mr Lansley with evidence of a specific example of NHS Sussex denying cataract operations because of cost considerations.

Mr Lansley said: 'We will not allow NHS commissioners to impose blanket bans. I will gladly take note of and investigate that example. ... I shall respond in writing about NHS Sussex and put a copy in the Library of the House.'

A Labour spokesman said the evidence had ‘forced [Mr Lansley] to commit to an investigation’.

Last month, GP magazine revealed that more than 90% of PCTs now impose thresholds or limits on referrals for procedures deemed 'non-urgent' or of 'low clinical value'.

Labour shadow health secretary Andy Burnham cited GP’s findings during a House of Commons debate on a motion about the NHS.

The motion referred to ‘mounting evidence of rationing of treatments and services by cost, despite ministers’ claims to have prevented it’. The motion also mentioned the ‘growing gap between ministers’ statements and what is happening in the NHS’.

Mr Burnham said: ‘I was talking about rationing, and let me focus on cataract surgery. GP magazine has found limits on cataract surgery in 66% of PCTs.’

After the parliamentary debate, Mr Burnham wrote to Mr Lansley to ask for a wider investigation into PCTs’ treatment restrictions.

Labour MP for Denton and Reddish Andrew Gwynne mentioned GP’s findings alongside Labour’s own investigation of the issue during a House of Commons debate this week.

‘Aside from the evidence presented by the Labour party and the GP magazine, verified by Full Fact, PCTs acknowledge that they are restricting access to bariatric surgery,’ he said.

Mr Gwynne said it was becoming ‘increasingly clear’ that there was ‘a gap between ministers’ statements on the NHS and people’s real experience of it on the ground’.

The motion was defeated, with 303 MPs voting against it and just 228 voting for it.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Half of GP partners say primary care networks will increase workload

Half of GP partners say primary care networks will increase workload

Half of GP partners think primary care networks (PCNs) will increase workload for...

GPC sessional chair among GPs taking lead roles in primary care networks

GPC sessional chair among GPs taking lead roles in primary care networks

GPC sessional subcommittee chair Dr Zoe Norris is among GPs set to become clinical...

Most locum and salaried GPs ignored as primary care networks form, poll reveals

Most locum and salaried GPs ignored as primary care networks form, poll reveals

Just one in 20 locum GPs are involved in setting up primary care networks (PCNs)...

Most GPs have too little time to discuss end of life care

Most GPs have too little time to discuss end of life care

Nearly three quarters of GPs have too little time to discuss end of life care with...

Majority of UK doctors are burnt out, study shows

Majority of UK doctors are burnt out, study shows

More than half of UK doctors are suffering from burnout, figures show - with work...

Why being a GP partner is still a great career choice

Why being a GP partner is still a great career choice

Being a GP partner provides greater opportunities for continuity of care and allows...