Junior doctors: The philosophical reality of the strike ballot result

Liverpool GP Dr Chris Mimnagh takes a philosophical look at the resounding vote by junior doctors in favour of industrial action - a mandate that could yet come into play early in 2016.

Philosophy - what's it all about? I've been looking into a bit of philosophy for a while now. Nothing too heavy, just the basics, kind of an idiot's guide. One concept among many that appeals to me is the idea that we create our own realities.

The classic example is Plato's cave, where people growing up in a cave believe shadows are reality and they fail to believe others when told that they are not seeing reality.

I thought about that when the juniors' ballot results came out. Those shadows are not reality, their interpretation is subjective, but the reality we create is the one we will defend.

Junior doctor revolt

Hence, to some, it's the end of professional medicine, while for others it's the mandate to lead a revolt against an unsafe imposition of working conditions, and for others it's the only logical choice.

Each will have their reality, self constructed, self policed, and self defended.

My point here is that whatever reality we create from the vote we should bear in mind that the ultimate reality, death, is never far away and whatever action we take we should try and avoid that reality happening to somebody in our care.

I'm totally in favour of the juniors becoming radicals - prepared to place long-term NHS interests over personal interests - it's what we need to transform our service into something fit for the future. Unless, of course, I'm just seeing shadows.

  • Dr Chris Mimnagh is a GP co-director of clinical strategy at the NHS partnership organisation Liverpool Health Partners

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

NICE recommends digital CBT for children with mild depression

NICE recommends digital CBT for children with mild depression

Children and young people with mild depression should have access to digital cognitive...

GPs taking early retirement triple in a decade as tax limits hit workforce

GPs taking early retirement triple in a decade as tax limits hit workforce

Numbers of GPs taking early retirement have tripled over the past decade as tighter...

BMA safety warning as pharmacists gain power to switch prescriptions

BMA safety warning as pharmacists gain power to switch prescriptions

Pharmacists are set to be granted emergency powers to alter patients' prescriptions...

GP funding could rise £60m through deals on QOF, networks and digital health

GP funding could rise £60m through deals on QOF, networks and digital health

GP leaders hope to trigger a 1% boost to practice funding from April - on top of...

GP trainees unfairly denied £20,000 golden hello payments, says BMA

GP trainees unfairly denied £20,000 golden hello payments, says BMA

Some GP trainees expecting £20,000 golden hellos for working in under-doctored areas...

The survival of GP partnerships depends on a credible workforce plan

The survival of GP partnerships depends on a credible workforce plan

The GP partnership review and the NHS long-term plan set out welcome proposals to...