Some integrated care systems could starve GPs of funding, warns RCGP chair

Integrated care systems 'simply won't work' in parts of England and could starve general practice of funding, RCGP chair Professor Martin Marshall has warned.

RCGP chair Professor Martin Marshall (Photo: Pete Hill)
RCGP chair Professor Martin Marshall (Photo: Pete Hill)

Speaking to GPonline, the RCGP chair said that the college supported greater integration in principle - even to the extent of pooling budgets across primary and secondary care within local areas or regions.

But he warned that although in some areas GPs' voice within local health systems was well established, in parts of the country dominated by powerful hospitals integration plans would not work.

In these areas in particular, NHS reform plans set out in a government white paper last month could lead to a reduction in funding for general practice - rather than the increased share of the health service budget the college and others have called for, Professor Marshall said.

Read more
>
GPs must define role of triage and remote consultations post-pandemic, says RCGP chair

As an academic who had studied integration over many years, the RCGP chair said he was well aware that there had been a string of policy initiatives that aimed to deliver integration over recent decades - and that 'none of them have worked very well'.

'I'm not expecting this to be easy territory in any way,' he said. 'But there's plenty of evidence that when you do have a well integrated system...you deliver better quality care at lower cost. We know that from international exemplars of good practice. So it's the right direction of travel.'

However, maintaining a strong voice for general practice within a re-shaped NHS landscape was crucial, he argued.

'That's where the issue around CCGs comes in. Whatever you think of their effectiveness over the last eight years, CCGs - because they've held budgets - have had a lot of influence on the way the systems work,' he said

NHS reform

'If CCGs are disestablished in the way that NHS England would like - and I understand why they might want that - the risk is that there won't be any force behind the GP voice, there won't be any incentives in the system to listen to GPs, and that's a concern.'

Professor Marshall said that integrated care systems with general practice and primary care as their foundation 'are the ones that work' - while those seeking to drive integration from hospitals 'don't work'.

'That's where my biggest concern lies - that general practice needs to have a very significant voice, a leadership voice, I'd say, in integrated care organisations, or integrated care systems.

'I am confident that in some parts of the country, the GP voice is sufficiently well established, relationships with hospital colleagues are sufficiently good for that to happen.

Integrated care systems

'But there are many other parts of the country where there hasn't been sufficient time to develop that collective GP voice, where there possibly isn't one, and where hospitals are very powerful - particularly in areas like cities where there are big teaching hospitals - where integrated care initiatives simply won't work, because they're driven by the hospitals rather than by general practice.'

In areas such as these, the RCGP chair warned - although pooled budgets in principle were 'exactly the right thing to do' to root out the 'dysfunction' that funding locked up in separate silos can create in health systems - funding could be sucked out of primary care.

'If you've got an integrated care system that doesn't work well, if the power is with the hospitals, the hospitals will demand more money and general practice will be starved and that would be a disaster,' Professor Marshall said.

In a speech at a virtual RCGP conference earlier this year, Professor Marshall argued that the share of NHS funding allocated to primary care - currently around 9% - should double, to bring the UK in line with some of the best-performing integrated care systems in the world.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Viewpoint: Why NICE guidance on domestic abuse needs to be updated

Viewpoint: Why NICE guidance on domestic abuse needs to be updated

Dr Vasumathy Sivarajasingam explains why screening for domestic abuse should be standard...

PCNs opt out of phase 2 of COVID-19 vaccination programme over workload pressure

PCNs opt out of phase 2 of COVID-19 vaccination programme over workload pressure

Some PCNs have opted out of phase 2 of the COVID-19 vaccination programme, with others...

UK COVID-19 vaccination programme tracker

UK COVID-19 vaccination programme tracker

GPs across the UK are playing a leading role in the largest-ever NHS vaccination...

CVT risk from COVID-19 infection 'significantly higher' than from vaccines, study suggests

CVT risk from COVID-19 infection 'significantly higher' than from vaccines, study suggests

The risk of cerebral venous thrombosis (CVT) following COVID-19 infection is eight...

‘Warm and kind’ retired Derbyshire GP dies from COVID-19

‘Warm and kind’ retired Derbyshire GP dies from COVID-19

Retired Derbyshire GP Dr Om Prakash Chawla, who was known for his warmth and kindness,...

GPs can learn from pandemic to strengthen relationship with patients, says RCGP chair

GPs can learn from pandemic to strengthen relationship with patients, says RCGP chair

General practice can build on changes to care during the COVID-19 pandemic to strengthen...