HPA condemns early swine flu containment measures

Containment measures during the early stages of the swine flu outbreak did not reduce the disease's spread, an HPA report has concluded.

Delays in providing prophylaxis to patients led to onward transmission (Photograph: SPL)
Delays in providing prophylaxis to patients led to onward transmission (Photograph: SPL)

The requirement for GPs to take samples from suspected cases also stretched the resources of the regional health protection units expected to coordinate this work.

In some areas the workload involved in the containment approach became unsustainable and testing could not be continued, the HPA said.

The report points out that the UK's approach to containment, which included testing of cases and provision of prophylaxis to patients and close contacts, was intended to slow the spread of infection and buy time.

It concludes that the impact of containment ‘is likely to have been small'. ‘It is also possible,' the report adds, 'that the containment measures during this period had no effect on the course of the pandemic.'

Comprehensive containment would 'inevitably' have been difficult to achieve for a variety of reasons, the HPA said.

Infection may have already been spreading readily before containment measures began. In addition, the virus was brought into the country repeatedly from different areas overseas and newly imported cases were not detected fast enough or completely enough.

Also, prophylaxis was not used in many cases, because mild symptoms meant many patients did not seek medical advice, and delays in providing prophylaxis to other patients led to onward transmission.

The report suggests that the limitations of the containment strategy, and need to move to a treatment phase, could have been recognised almost two months before the DoH decided to abandon it.

‘From early June there was increasing evidence of transmission in the wider community,' the HPA said.

‘This suggested that a containment approach was unlikely to be effective. Arguably, the containment approach should have been stopped at this time to be replaced by a treatment-only approach.'

Visit our Swine Flu Resource Centre

Tom Moberly recommends

Swine Flu Resource Centre

Read more

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in