Healthy obesity a myth, study finds

Obesity raises the risk of MI and stroke even when traditional risk factors such as high BP or cholesterol are absent, according to a study that overturns the idea obesity can be 'benign' in some people.

Obesity: research scotches health myth

Studies had suggested that some obese people may not face an increased risk of cardiovascular disease if their metabolic profile – including levels of blood sugar, cholesterol and other factors – is normal.

But a new meta-analysis has found that having a BMI of 30 for 10 years or more increases the risk of cardiovascular disease or death by a quarter – even among those who are metabolically ‘healthy’.

Authors of the study said clinicians and patients should not see obesity as a harmless condition. Doctors should consider both BMI and metabolic factors when assessing a person’s risk of cardiovascular disease, they said.

'No healthy obesity'

The international team of researchers examined data from eight studies into the effect of weight and metabolic profile on the risk of heart disease and death.

They analysed pooled data from 61,386 patients. There were 3,988 clinical events, including MI, acute coronary syndrome, heart failure, stroke and all-cause mortality.

Compared with metabolically healthy people of normal weight, people with a normal metabolic profile and a BMI over 30 faced a 24% increased relative risk of a cardiovascular event or death. This translates to a 0.7% greater absolute risk over 10-11 years.

In contrast, all metabolically unhealthy people had a similar risk of cardiovascular disease regardless of their BMI. This was more than double the risk of a metabolically healthy, normal-weight person.

Study authors said the concept of ‘benign obesity’ suggested by previous studies may only represent a short-term picture. Data suggests excess weight is linked to the initial development of unseen metabolic and vascular problems that lead to cardiovascular events in the longer term, they said.

The authors said: ‘Our results do not support this concept of "benign obesity" and demonstrate that there is no "healthy" pattern of obesity.’

They added: ‘Our findings highlight the need for comprehensive evaluation of not only BMI but also metabolic factors for the prediction of future morbidity and mortality.’

Particular attention should be given to normal-weight patients with an unhealthy metabolic profile, they advised.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

phone and laptop

Blanket rollout of patient record access programme halted

Plans to roll out access for all patients to prospective entries to their GP medical...

GP sign

Scottish GP capacity hits lowest point in more than a decade

Scotland has lost 3% of its full-time equivalent (FTE) GP workforce since 2019 -...


GPs fear funding cuts and sidelining of LMCs as ICS model beds in

GPs fear hospital trust overspends could become 'general practice's problem' as representation...

Doctor on a computer

3 reasons why recruiting with GP Jobs makes your life easier

How GP Jobs can help you fill vacancies in your practice.

Amoxicillin antibiotic drug capsules

Viewpoint: How can we reduce antibiotic prescribing?

Dr Anita Sharma, who has been involved with several antibiotic prescribing initiatives...

Person typing on laptop

Complaints against GPs up 37% compared with pre-pandemic levels

Written complaints about GP practices have surged by more than a third compared with...