GPs should use clinical judgement to adjust test scores for dementia

GPs assessing patients for dementia should rely on clinical judgement over psychological test scores, according to Dr David Anderson, consultant in old age psychiatry at Mersey Care NHS Trust.

Speaking at Primary Care Live, Dr Anderson said a focus on psychological instruments, such the mini mental state exam (MMSE), overlooked the fact that these instruments are validated against clinical judgement.

"People are beginning to believe that the instrument is the gold standard and asking whether we as clinicians can compare with the instrument," he said. "But we are the gold standard and it would be a tragedy if these instruments replaced clinical skill and clinical expertise."

He said that the MMSE test was used particularly badly because it was misunderstood. "In uninformed hands this is an extremely dangerous instrument," he said. "This is a cognitive screening assessment. It is not a diagnostic tool."

"If you use it, be aware of its limitations," he said.

In addition to not being designed as a dementia screening tool, MMSE has an internal variation of three points either side of the score given, it does not include an assessment of executive function and it is greatly dependent on the educational attainment and factors such as depression. An MMSE score needs to be interpreted in the same way as a blood test result, he stressed.

tom.moberly@haymarket.com

Comment below and tell us what you think

 

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Most children could be removed from shielded patient list, deputy CMO suggests

Most children could be removed from shielded patient list, deputy CMO suggests

Most children could be removed from the shielded patient list in a future wave of...

GPs can provide some care for shielded patients in clinical settings, NHS England confirms

GPs can provide some care for shielded patients in clinical settings, NHS England confirms

GPs can provide care to shielded patients in 'infection-controlled clinical settings'...

How digital assistants can help patients manage their health and wellbeing

How digital assistants can help patients manage their health and wellbeing

A project in Staffordshire has shown how practices can make use of digital technology...

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

GPonline provides an overview of the key guidance relating to coronavirus, including...

Fair death-in-service deal for locums vital before second COVID-19 wave, warns BMA

Fair death-in-service deal for locums vital before second COVID-19 wave, warns BMA

The government must do ‘the right thing’ and secure adequate death-in-service benefits...

GP workload fears over antibody testing rollout for 'no clinical benefit'

GP workload fears over antibody testing rollout for 'no clinical benefit'

GP practices are being contacted by patients asking for antibody tests as the government...