GPs refuse to police NHS access in £500m migrant fees plan

Practices must not be burdened with policing access to primary care, GP leaders have warned, after a government-commissioned report claimed the NHS could raise up to £500m by charging visitors to use health services.

Dr Nagpaul: Charging migrants may push up demands on emergency care (Photo: Jason Heath Lancy)

The study, consisting of two reports by Creative Research and Prederi, was released as MPs prepared to debate the immigration bill later on Tuesday, which would introduce a £200 healthcare surcharge for temporary migrants.

The DH also plans to establish a new system to recover costs, which aims 'to tackle this issue and deter abuse of the system'.

RCGP chairwoman Dr Clare Gerada said GPs 'should not be expected to police access to healthcare', while GPC chairman Dr Chaand Nagpaul said there was limited evidence of overseas visitors ‘consuming large parts of the NHS budget’.

'Based on assumptions'

The DH-commissioned report estimates that £388m is spent by the NHS each year on visitors who should be charged, and between £70m and £300m on so-called 'health tourists'.

The DH estimates that with £200m gained from the surcharge, £388m from charging visitors, and the deterrent effect on health tourism, total savings will add up to £500m. 

Previous official estimates put the cost to the NHS of overseas visitors at around £20m.

Dr Nagpaul said: ‘The government’s estimates are based on a number of assumptions that result in a figure significantly higher than previous estimates.’

GPs do not have the capacity to administer extended charging, he said, which would put additional strain on ‘already overstretched GP services’.

Dr Nagpaul added: ‘We must also be careful about creating a climate where some people are deterred from seeking treatment when they need it.

'Not only would this present a risk to the health of that individual, it could also prevent the NHS from identifying individuals with contagious diseases and result in further costs to the NHS should a patient's condition deteriorate to the extent they require more expensive emergency treatment later on.’

Dr Gerada welcomed research into the issue but said it was important to note many of the statistics in the report are 'based on approximate figures' and should be treated with caution.

Commenting on proposals to reclaim costs, she said: 'The most important issue continues to be implementation. It is imperative that GPs are not tasked with being a "new border agency" in policing the NHS.

'Limiting access to NHS services will fundamentally change one of the founding principles of general practice – that healthcare is free at the point of need.

'GPs have a duty of care to all people seeking healthcare, and should not be expected to police access to healthcare and turn people away when they are at their most vulnerable.'

She said the college 'strongly opposed' the extra administrative duties for GPs and practice staff that could be created as a result of the proposals.

Health secretary Jeremy Hunt said: ‘With the NHS already under pressure from an ageing population, it cannot be right that large amounts of taxpayers’ money is being lost through treating people who should be paying from foreign countries.

‘These independent reports prove this is a serious problem that the government was right to address. We are confident our new measures will make the NHS fairer and more sustainable for the British families and taxpayers it was set up to serve.’

Labour’s shadow health secretary Andy Burnham said the announcement was ‘more about spin than substance’.

‘The government’s own report undermines their headline-grabbing figures, admitting they are based on old and incomplete data.'

He said: ‘Labour would not support changes that make doctors and nurses surrogate immigration officials.’

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

Andrea Leadsom

DHSC confirms new minister responsible for general practice

Andrea Leadsom has been confirmed as the new DHSC minister for primary care and general...


Government must match consultants' pay offer in new contract for GPs

GPs have warned they could be forced into industrial action if the government fails...

Consultants in London on strike earlier this year

Consultants to vote on new pay deal to end strikes

Consultants will vote on a government pay offer that would increase salaries by up...

BMA England GP committee chair Dr Katie Bramall-Stainer (Photo: Sarah Turton/BMA)

GPs' willingness to take collective action will underpin contract talks

GPs' willingness to take part in 'once in a generation' collective action will underpin...

GP consultation

GPs out of work 'because practices can’t afford to hire them', warns GP leader

Growing numbers of GPs are struggling to find work - with some considering moving...

computer and stethoscope

Petition demanding SCA exam refund collects almost 2,000 signatures

Almost 2,000 people have signed a petition demanding refunds for doctors whose GP...