GPC condemns criticism of GP pay as 'out of date'

MPs' criticism of GP pay rises under the new GMS contract has been condemned by the GPC as 'based on an out-of-date understanding of the current situation'.

Laurence Buckman
Laurence Buckman

Report 'NHS Pay Modernisation: New Contracts for GP Services in England', published today by the Public Accounts Committee, says GP income increased by 58 per cent since 2003.

GPC chairman Dr Laurence Buckman said: ‘The GP contract is now quite different to the deal originally agreed in 2003 and much of the criticism in this report is based on an out-of-date understanding of the current situation.

‘Issues such as the phasing out of MPIG are already being worked on through negotiation. We want to reduce practices' reliance on MPIG and create a fairer system but if it's done too quickly it will damage practices and the services they provide for patients.'

Practice income rose sharply after 2003 but global sums have been frozen for the last three years. GPC deputy chairman Dr Richard Vautrey told the RCGP's annual conference in Bournemouth last week that the credit crunch meant pay awards will be ‘a challenge for next few years'.

The report shows that the overspend on the first three years of the new GMS contract was recouped by the end of March this year.

It estimates the overspend at £1.8 billion between 2003/4 and 2005/6.

It says: ‘The DoH believes the cost of the contract is now under closer control and that by the end of 2008 it will have recovered any overspend.'

However, the supplementary evidence in the 52-page report shows that NHS chief executive David Nicholson put the overspend at £400 million, rather than £1.8 billion.

The report adds: ‘There is evidence that the DoH reduced its estimation of performance under the framework when budgeting for the increased cost due to the MPIG.'

In evidence to the PAC in March Mr Nicholson said: ‘It's true that we did overspend the amount of money available to us but in the last two years we will have clawed the money back.'

The report estimates that the major reasons for the overspend were the extra costs of the quality framework (£332 million) after practice performance exceeded expectation and the higher price of allowing practices to opt out of 24-hour responsibility (£182 million).

Report recommendations include piloting major change so cost can be more accurately predicted.

Another recommendation is that: ‘The DoH should consider replacing the MPIG with a redesigned global sum allocation in order to move the money into areas of greatest need.'

Another recommendation calls for the quality framework to be better aligned with national health priorities, giving greater priority to outcomes rather than procedures.

The report adds that in 2006/7 71 per cent of PCTs did not spend their allocation for local enhanced services.

‘These allocations were expected to be the minimum level that a trust would spend on enhanced services,' it adds.

Shadow Conservative health secretary Andrew Lansley said: ‘It is important that GPs are properly rewarded for their hard work, but the government's complete failure to understand the level of service they provide has left us with the worst of all worlds - GPs paid more than originally intended but left demotivated by how they have been treated.'

Shadow Liberal Democrat health secretary Norman Lamb said: ‘The government's handling of the GP contract has been staggeringly incompetent.'

neil.durham@haymarket.com

Comment below and tell us what you think

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

More than half of GP locums have seen a significant drop in income due to COVID-19

More than half of GP locums have seen a significant drop in income due to COVID-19

More than half of GP locums have experienced a significant fall in their income during...

How a GP helped develop a protective shield to cover patients needing CPR in the pandemic

How a GP helped develop a protective shield to cover patients needing CPR in the pandemic

Wiltshire GP Dr Lydia Campbell-Hill explains how she helped create a mini isolation...

GP practices can now sign up to new online PPE portal

GP practices can now sign up to new online PPE portal

GP practices will be able to register with the DHSC's new online PPE portal, which...

Fully-qualified GP workforce fell by 712 over the past year

Fully-qualified GP workforce fell by 712 over the past year

The fully-qualified GP workforce in England fell by 2.5%, losing 712 full-time equivalent...

MPs call for expert guidance on medico-legal implications of pandemic

MPs call for expert guidance on medico-legal implications of pandemic

A group of MPs has called on the government to set up an independent expert committee...

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

GPonline provides an overview of the key guidance relating to coronavirus, including...