GP data system GPES 'flawed, delayed and over budget', audit finds

An IT system that collects data from GP practices is technically flawed, despite coming in three times over budget and four years late, an audit of the GP Extraction Service (GPES) has found.

Dr Vautrey: 'Big IT projects are not only challenging, but don’t deliver what they’re expected to deliver.'
Dr Vautrey: 'Big IT projects are not only challenging, but don’t deliver what they’re expected to deliver.'

The Health and Social Care Information Centre (HSCIC) has come under heavy criticism for its delivery of the £40m GP Extraction Service (GPES), which it inherited from the NHS Information Centre in 2013. GPES was designed to ease QOF payments and allow clinical data to be extracted for analysis.

The costs of planning and implementing GPES was originally £14m but rose to £40m, with a further £5.5m of ‘write-offs and delay costs’, a report from the National Audit Office (NAO) has revealed.

The system was intended to allow health organisations such as NICE and the MHRA to request information, but so far only NHS England has received data, the report says.

GPES was meant to be in place by 2010 but was significantly delayed, only coming into use in April last year.

More expenditure will be needed to ‘improve or replace’ the service, the NAO said.

Unacceptable flaws

‘It’s yet another example of how big IT projects are not only challenging, but don’t deliver what they’re expected to deliver,’ Dr Richard Vautrey, deputy chairman of the GPC, told GPonline.

‘Practices are still having to add things on a manual basis and this is unacceptable. It’s adding extra work to overworked practice managers.’

A statement from HSCIC says that the procurement and design of GPES, which took place before HSCIC was set up, ‘was not good enough’.

HSCIC said its first priority to improve the system was to facilitate QOF payments last April, which were delayed due to data collection problems.

It now has a new team of technical experts in place to ‘stabilise the service’.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

'Unrealistic' wage bands could mean PCNs lose funding for new staff

'Unrealistic' wage bands could mean PCNs lose funding for new staff

Salary bands for clinical pharmacists working in primary care networks (PCNs) are...

GP at Hand now has third largest patient list in England

GP at Hand now has third largest patient list in England

Controversial digital-first provider GP at Hand now has the third largest registered...

Why the RCGP should change its stance on assisted dying

Why the RCGP should change its stance on assisted dying

The RCGP is currently surveying members for their views on assisted dying. Dr Zoe...

RCGP urges caution over call to scrap home visits

RCGP urges caution over call to scrap home visits

Workload pressures are forcing GP practices into tough decisions about which services...

Labour promises 5,000 GP training posts and premises boost in £26bn 'NHS rescue plan'

Labour promises 5,000 GP training posts and premises boost in £26bn 'NHS rescue plan'

The Labour party has promised a £26bn real-terms increase in NHS funding by 2023/24...

European GPs registering to work in NHS dropped after Brexit referendum

European GPs registering to work in NHS dropped after Brexit referendum

The number of European GPs registering to work in the UK has dropped since the 2016...