How GP consortia will take charge of commissioning

The Health White Paper sketches out a new role for GPs, but has not filled in all the gaps. Tom Ireland reports.

Dr Jenner: 'Any clause tying practices to risk, balancing the budget, or a potential loss of their provider contract will be a deal-breaker for the BMA' (Photograph: Mike Alsford)
Dr Jenner: 'Any clause tying practices to risk, balancing the budget, or a potential loss of their provider contract will be a deal-breaker for the BMA' (Photograph: Mike Alsford)

The long-awaited DoH White Paper is finally out, with a strong message for GPs: if you are not part of a consortium, you need to find one quick.

The White Paper may pose more questions than it answers, but it carries a massive amount of detail to digest.

By 2012, legislation will be in place forcing all practices in England with a registered list to be part of a commissioning group. But how will the network of consortia operate?


Accountable officer
By April 2013, each GP consortium must have an 'accountable officer' to take financial control of budgets from its PCT.

As PCTs and SHAs are abolished, a new NHS Commissioning Board will calculate practice-level budgets, based on list size and deprivation, and allocate them directly to the consortia.

The commissioning board will hold each consortium to account for 'stewardship of NHS resources' and outcomes of its population. In turn, each consortium will hold its constituent practices to account against these same objectives.

Unlike fundholding, GPs will not be able to profit from savings the consortium makes, nor will they be liable for financial losses.

The consortium will instead receive a 'management fee' to pay GPs for their time (or to pay third parties for support) with a 'premium' available for those achieving high quality outcomes or financial performance.

Health secretary Andrew Lansley is still concerned about potential conflicts of interest however, which leads to a quirk of the policy: GP consortia will be responsible for commissioning almost all NHS services except those they know best - primary medical services.

GP contracts and services will be commissioned directly by the NHS Commissioning Board, another big job for it alongside all the other commissioning GPs will not take part in, like pharmacy and dentistry.

The White Paper also sets out plans to move to 'a single contractual and funding model' for practices. This new contract is likely to include aspects of the APMS contract (it pledges to 'promote quality improvement' and 'remove barriers to new provision') and may signal the end of PMS contracts.

GPs will still be monitored by the CQC, and despite Mr Lansley's pledge to scrap many NHS quangos, his White Paper seems to have created new ones and made the largest ones even larger.

The CQC will be 'strengthened' as a quality inspectorate, while incorporating Healthwatch England, a new body that will respond to patient and public complaints. Monitor will take over the regulation of all providers, including GP practices, as well as being the 'economic regulator', setting prices for the NHS services commissioners will buy.

Vast gaps in detail
Due to the vast scope of Mr Lansley's proposals, the gaps in detail gape open like vast craters.

Commissioning groups will 'not be bailed out', says the White Paper, but the question remains: what will the DoH do if consortia overspend or are incompetent?

Justin Cumberlege, a primary care legal expert from Carter Lemon Camerons, says the policy is 'naive' and fails to address two big questions.

'The first is how membership between partners in the consortium will be arranged, legally. And the second is termination: What happens if they fail?

'They might be able to fly in a new chief executive, but the members of the consortia will always be the same.'

The GP contract will be adjusted to include clauses to force practices to commission via a consortium, but it is unknown what level of responsibility individual practices will have to take on and how they will be overseen by the consortia.

Dr David Jenner, GMS/PMS lead at the NHS Alliance, believes practices will have to demonstrate 'efficient use of resources and that they have 'stuck to agreed care pathways'.

'Any clause tying practices to risk, balancing the budget, or a potential loss of their provider contract will be a deal-breaker for the BMA,' he says.

Dr Darin Seiger, chairman of one of the UK's most advanced practice-based commissioning groups, Nene Commissioning, says practices in his group merely 'bring the views of the practice' to consortia meetings.

Those who want to can put themselves forward to be elected to the board, but otherwise, '99 per cent of GPs will simply have to focus on their activity and help analyse any potential variation', he said.

The GPC has made it clear it wants the bare minimum enforced contractually - nothing more than a few clauses to make GPs 'consider' the resources their patients use.

How well BMA negotiations progress will inform many of the finer points in the practice/consortia relationship. More detail may also come in a series of consultation papers expected soon.

Despite the uncertainty, and concerns that the profession will resist taking on its new role, Dr Seiger is confident the new model will work - and will be better for GPs than PCT commissioning.

'(A GP consortium) is a supportive model. No-one's telling anyone off. We won't focus on finance as GPs aren't interested in it. We look at clinical activity and getting the best outcomes, which is what GPs want to do.'

A prototype consortium: Nene Commissioning

Dr Seiger: Nene chairman

  • Nene Commissioning, based in Northamptonshire, is made up of 350 GPs from 76 practices, split into four localities. The group commissions care for more than 657,000 patients, or 98 per cent of the county's population.
  • The group is clinically led and supported by a team of less than 20 managers and administrative staff.
  • Member practices sign a 'participating practice agreement' which ensures they attend meetings and review their clinical activity when necessary.
  • A GP or practice manager is paid hourly by Nene to attend locality meetings.
  • Each locality elects two GP representatives to form the consortium board.
  • Nene's board is made up of nine GPs in all, two practice managers and a chief executive.
  • The group is a social enterprise and community interest organisation.

Tom Ireland recommends

Health White Paper 2010

Read more

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus