GP anger as shielding advice changed 'without warning'

GPs have hit out at a lack of warning over changes to advice for patients on shielding lists, warning that confusion could put patient safety at risk and lead to a spike in practice workload.

BMA GP committee chair Dr Richard Vautrey
BMA GP committee chair Dr Richard Vautrey

Just 48 hours after an updated primary care standard operating procedure (SOP) published on 29 May said patients at highest risk from COVID-19 were being asked to 'shield themselves and stay at home', the government confirmed that guidance for shielding patients had been relaxed.

Communities secretary Robert Jenrick said on 31 May: 'We have updated the shielded guidance so that from 1 June people will be advised that they can take initial steps to safely spend time outdoors.

'Those shielding will be able to spend time outdoors with members of their own household or if they live alone with one person from another household. This reflects a lower risk of transmission outdoors as well as the significantly reduced prevalence of COVID-19 in the community. You must still follow social distancing guidelines and remain at a 2m distance from others.'

Shielding list

GP leaders said they had not been consulted ahead of the change in advice - and have yet to receive any further clarification, warning that it was 'imperative' general practice was kept informed on changes in guidance to be able to support patients.

The sudden change is the latest aspect of the shielding process to have caused confusion and concern in general practice - a senior NHS England official apologised in April and admitted the process had been 'really frustrating' after problems including patients being missed out or incorrectly identified for shielding, and changes to guidance on who should be included.

BMA GP committee chair Dr Richard Vautrey told GPonline: 'GP practices have spent a significant amount of time supporting their patients who are at the highest risk from COVID-19 and who have been told to shield.

'Patients are also often contacted by their practice to make sure they understand what shielding means and that they have support if needed - such as deliveries of medication.

COVID-19 guidance

'However, to be able to give appropriate advice to patients, GPs need to be kept up-to-date with Government guidance and consulted on any potential changes to it; changes that directly impact the lives of those in their communities.

'Practices received the updated SOP guidance on Saturday 30 May, which contained detailed advice on the management for shielding patients, and yet only a few hours later the guidance appeared to have changed without warning, and practices still have not received any further clarification.

'It's therefore, imperative that practices are informed before public announcements, on any subject matter, so that they are in a position to support their patients as effectively as possible. Covid-19 is potentially very dangerous for those with underlying health conditions, and it is only right that we, as their family doctors, are properly prepared for any changes to guidance around their care.'

Northumberland LMC medical secretary Dr Jane Lothian said a spike in calls to GP practices was likely from patients concerned about what the change in advice meant for them.

GP workload

She said that the original 12-week period for which patients had been asked to shield was not due to run out until the end of June - adding: 'I was expecting we'd have a massive job on our hands at that stage talking to these people and reviewing them.'

Dr Lothian said the change had come without warning and was likely to cause a 'great deal of confusion among patients'. She said practices had not been given the information they needed to advise patients on how to change their behaviour in light of the updated advice.

Doctors questioned the sudden change on social media, with one asking: 'Why on earth would you announce this without first communicating with primary care teams?'

NHS England primary care medical director Dr Nikki Kanani said she had 'understandably' received a number of queries about the changed advice and promised more information 'as soon as I know more'.

A DHSC spokesperson said the government had consulted 'extensively' with NHS leaders during the pandemic and hit out at reports that shielding guidance had been changed without NHS England's knowledge.

The spokesperson said: 'It is a complete fabrication to suggest that NHS England were not aware of the shielding guidance being updated.

'We have engaged extensively with partners and the healthcare system throughout this process and will continue to do so when more substantive measures are considered.

'We want to make life easier for the most vulnerable and, as the number of COVID-19 cases continues to fall, the evidence shows those shielding can spend time safely outside if they wish, as long as they follow social distancing guidelines.'

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Locum GPs 'sucked up' by private sector as COVID-19 hits income

Locum GPs 'sucked up' by private sector as COVID-19 hits income

Locum GPs have been 'sucked up' by private sector healthcare providers as the COVID-19...

MPs demand urgent action on NHS backlog and routine COVID-19 tests for staff

MPs demand urgent action on NHS backlog and routine COVID-19 tests for staff

MPs have demanded urgent action to prevent avoidable harm to patients from the NHS...

Freeze QOF and deliver COVID cash or second wave will overwhelm GPs, BMA warns

Freeze QOF and deliver COVID cash or second wave will overwhelm GPs, BMA warns

GP practices will be unable to cope with a second wave of COVID-19 unless urgent...

Reducing our practice's carbon footprint by appropriate inhaler prescribing

Reducing our practice's carbon footprint by appropriate inhaler prescribing

Dr Vasu Siva explains how her practice is aiming to cut its carbon emissions by targeting...

RCGP chair warns of 'significant problem' over flu vaccine supplies

RCGP chair warns of 'significant problem' over flu vaccine supplies

The NHS faces a 'significant problem' with flu vaccine supplies as it aims to cover...

GMC overhauls consent advice to improve patient involvement in decisions about care

GMC overhauls consent advice to improve patient involvement in decisions about care

The GMC has overhauled its guidance on patient consent - setting out seven key principles...