GMC ready for challenge over proof

The GMC is bracing itself for a High Court challenge in the wake of lowering the standard of proof in fitness-to-practise cases, according to its president.

GMC president Professor Sir Graeme Catto said: 'It is a new law and should any doctor feel it wasn't applied fairly, I suspect, as with any major change, we will end up in the High Court.'

The introduction of the civil standard of proof in fitness-to-practise cases, rather than the criminal standard, will start from April 2008, the GMC hopes.

The GMC has published a summary of responses to the consultation on how the changes should be implemented.

Almost without exception, responses from individual members of the profession argued against the civil standard of proof, the report said.

The GMC president was defiant, saying: 'We are talking about 50 doctors out of all the doctors in the country.'

The consultation was meant to establish how to implement the changes, but the BMA was frustrated that there was no consultation on whether to make the changes in the first place.

Paul Phillip, GMC director of standards and fitness to practise, said there were many organisations in favour of the move and that most government regulators used the civil standard. He later admitted that the majority of health organisations were probably against the move.

GPC chairman Dr Richard Vautrey said the BMA would continue to fight to reverse the decision. 'Doctors remain to be convinced. Under huge pressure, in high-profile cases, you can see the GMC making decisions that might not be fair.'

Sir Graeme said: 'It would be helpful if the BMA had seen the advantage of the move. It allows us to address the less serious cases we see to ensure doctors abide by conditions of practice.'

Under the new standard, a fact will be established if it is more than likely to have happened. The current criminal standard means a case must be proved beyond reasonable doubt.

The GMC has said the civil standard will be flexible, meaning serious allegations will require more convincing evidence.


Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

Prime minister Rishi Sunak speaking at the Conservatives party conference

Sunak announces plan to phase out smoking in England

The government has set out plans to phase out smoking in England by making it illegal...

Stethoscope on a computer keyboard

US health firm cleared for £1.2bn EMIS takeover

US health giant UnitedHealth has been officially cleared for a £1.2bn takeover of...

BMA sign

NHS England undermined safe planning for strikes, warns BMA

Doctors' leaders have hit out at NHS England in a strongly-worded letter warning...

Medicines on shelves

Dispensing practices face cashflow crisis as 'yo-yoing' fees fall sharply

Hundreds of dispensing practices across England face cashflow problems that could...

Female GP on a phone call wearing a headset

Seeing patients in person after multiple remote consultations

Dr Ellie Mein, medico-legal adviser at the Medical Defence Union (MDU), suggests...


Golden hello scheme brings in almost 3,000 new GP partners

Almost 3,000 GPs have become partners for the first time under a scheme offering...