GMC group is set to review fitness-to-practise process

A GMC working group is to investigate a rise in the duration of fitness-to-practise hearings and offer advice on how the process could be improved.

Dr Devlin: long fitness-to-practice hearings are 'not in anyone's interest' (Photograph: Steffan Hill)
Dr Devlin: long fitness-to-practice hearings are 'not in anyone's interest' (Photograph: Steffan Hill)

The move follows warnings from medico-legal experts that lengthier hearings are causing doctors greater financial and psychological stress.

Dr Michael Devlin, head of medical advisory services at the Medical Defence Union (MDU), said there was 'no doubt' cases had become longer and more complex in the past decade.

The number of heads of charge - specific claims made against a doctor - proposed by the GMC in an average case had risen sharply, he said.

'In the past, 10 to 15 heads of charge might have been the average. (Now) it is not unusual to have in excess of 50 heads of charge,' Dr Devlin said.

He added that because adjudicators on fitness-to-practise panels are paid a daily rate there may be a disincentive for cases to be wrapped up quickly.

Dr Devlin said lengthy hearings were 'not in anyone's interest'. He said: 'If we are talking about a three-week hearing, which is then resumed three or four months later, then all this is hanging over the doctor.

'There may well be interim conditions or suspensions while the hearing plays out, which causes all sorts of pressures - financial and psychological.'

Long hearings have 'obvious cost implications', both for the GMC and defence organisations, he added.

He said: 'These costs are often borne by the profession on both sides, so it hits doctors in the pocket.'

A GMC spokeswoman said procedures could be improved, and a working group had been set up to look at the issues. She said there was no evidence that panels unduly extended hearing length.

'The GMC is committed to delivering independent adjudication in a cost-effective and proportionate way,' she said.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

One in 20 GPs have sought help from specialist NHS mental health service

One in 20 GPs have sought help from specialist NHS mental health service

More than one in 20 GPs have sought help from a specialist NHS mental health service...

Government 'ignoring BMA warnings' as pension taxes force doctors to quit

Government 'ignoring BMA warnings' as pension taxes force doctors to quit

The government is ignoring warnings that doctors will be forced to cut back their...

Consultation skills: Breaking bad news

Consultation skills: Breaking bad news

Breaking bad news is always a difficult area for GPs, due to the complexity of the...

Power to freeze pensions for doctors facing unproven charges 'against natural justice'

Power to freeze pensions for doctors facing unproven charges 'against natural justice'

Powers that allow the health secretary to suspend NHS pension benefits for doctors...

GPs drop out of high-profile hospital integration scheme

GPs drop out of high-profile hospital integration scheme

The number of GP practices subcontracted to a West Midlands hospital trust as part...

GP practices could face legal action over unpaid service charges

GP practices could face legal action over unpaid service charges

GP practices operating from NHS-owned premises could face legal action if they fail...