GMC backs changes to standard of proof

The GMC has backed calls for a civil standard of proof to apply in fitness-to-practise cases, and the end of professionally-led regulation.

In its response to ‘Good Doctors, Safer Patients’, the council called for a sliding scale of proof to apply according to the severity of potential sanctions, a suggestion already backed by CMO Sir Liam Donaldson (GP, 3 November).

The GMC response says: ‘The rigour of the criminal standard of proof, or a standard close to it, is appropriate when contemplating erasure. The consequences of sanctions are less profound and the standard of proof can be applied more flexibly.’

The GMC has also called for a 50–50 split between lay and medical representation on its council. However, the GMC rejected the CMO’s suggestion it should be stripped of its adjudication role in fitness-to-practise cases.

GMC chief executive Finlay Scott said: ‘If the DoH decides, despite objective evidence, that we would do well to separate adjudication from the GMC, we would want to ensure that the new system was fair and workable.’

The GMC opposed the transfer of responsibility for regulating undergraduate medical education to the Postgraduate Medical Education Training Board and said it should continue to oversee the PLAB test. It rejected plans for a network of local GMC affiliates in every NHS organisation.

GMC president Sir Graeme Catto said: ‘One way to bridge the gap between local and national regulation could be affiliates at SHA level.’

GPC chairman Dr Hamish Meldrum said: ‘The BMA does not want to see a change in the standard of proof. The sliding scale would be a change from the criminal standard and means getting into difficult legal territory.’

nick.bostock@haymarket.com

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Five GP practices a week inspected by CQC during pandemic second wave

Five GP practices a week inspected by CQC during pandemic second wave

The CQC has inspected five GP practices a week in England since the second wave of...

Pregnant women and under-18s will not be offered COVID-19 vaccine

Pregnant women and under-18s will not be offered COVID-19 vaccine

Pregnant women, children and under-18s will not be recommended for routine COVID-19...

GP training: How an audit e-portfolio log entry is assessed

GP training: How an audit e-portfolio log entry is assessed

The second of two articles on audit during GP training looks at how the quality improvement...

GP training: Writing up an audit for your e-portfolio

GP training: Writing up an audit for your e-portfolio

In the first of two articles on how to write up an audit, a typical e-portfolio entry...

UK ups order of 95% effective COVID-19 vaccine by 2m doses

UK ups order of 95% effective COVID-19 vaccine by 2m doses

The UK has increased its order of the 95% effective Moderna COVID-19 vaccine to 7m...

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

Coronavirus: Key guidance GPs need to know about COVID-19

GPonline provides an overview of the key guidance relating to coronavirus, including...