Focus on cost hits quality of successful APMS bids

PCTs are rejecting high-quality GP bids to run new APMS practices, because of a relentless focus on short-term costs, a think tank has warned.

Josh Ryan-Collins, a researcher at the New Economics Foundation (NEF), said that PCTs were expected to make annual 3-5 per cent efficiency savings across their budgets.

As a result, instead of prioritising quality, commissioners are choosing providers entirely on price. This means that higher quality but more expensive bids are often rejected - even if they would save money elsewhere in the NHS by improving outcomes.

'Focusing on price is an easy way out of having to make difficult decisions,' said Mr Ryan-Collins. 'If you want sustainable public services, you have to think about both inputs and long-term impact.'

NEF is calling for the current system of competitive tendering to be replaced by a new model focusing on 'public benefit'.

This would allow commissioners to take into account savings from other parts of the public purse, and wider benefits.

Camden Council has piloted NEF's system in its procurement of adult social care services. It chose a consortium of small, local providers, whose bid was not the cheapest, but which offered other benefits to the local community.

Such a system would likely benefit GPs, whose bids to provide services are often more expensive than those from private companies, but which include public health work and 'intangibles' such as links with the community.

Dr Kambiz Boomla, a GP in Tower Hamlets, east London, whose bid to run a local practice lost out to a cheaper bid from Atos Healthcare, said it was clear that commissioning on price alone wouldn't produce the outcomes patients wanted.

But he called for PCTs to tender contracts at a fixed price, to force bidders to compete on quality. 'Once you bring price into it, you're always trading price against quality,' he said.

jonn.elledge@haymarket.com

Comment below and tell us what you think

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Government outlines PPE supply plans as GPs remain in dark over reimbursement

Government outlines PPE supply plans as GPs remain in dark over reimbursement

The government has outlined plans to provide 'an uninterrupted supply' of PPE during...

Four in five GPs report heavy workload as COVID-19 second wave builds

Four in five GPs report heavy workload as COVID-19 second wave builds

Four in five GPs say their practice is currently facing levels of workload that are...

Medeconomics Live: Bringing you the latest in practice management thinking

Medeconomics Live: Bringing you the latest in practice management thinking

The one-day, virtual Medeconomics Live conference aims to provide essential insights...

First COVID-19 jabs to target care home residents and staff under new JCVI advice

First COVID-19 jabs to target care home residents and staff under new JCVI advice

Older adults living in care homes and staff working there will be first to receive...

GPs unable to veto virtual fitness to practise hearings during pandemic

GPs unable to veto virtual fitness to practise hearings during pandemic

GPs facing fitness to practise investigations during the COVID-19 pandemic will be...

Government rejects major NHSPS overhaul - but changes 'could ease GP service charge disputes'

Government rejects major NHSPS overhaul - but changes 'could ease GP service charge disputes'

A government review has rejected calls for a major overhaul of an NHS Property Services...