Female-only HPV vaccination leaves men exposed to cancers, study warns

Vaccinating girls against the HPV vaccine still leaves men 'at risk of cancers associated with the virus' despite a protective herd effect, researchers have warned.

HPV jab: research suggests expanding coverage to boys (Photo: Consolidated Scotland)
HPV jab: research suggests expanding coverage to boys (Photo: Consolidated Scotland)

A Danish study showed that vaccinating 90% of girls against the virus would cut incidence of anal, penile and oropharyngeal cancers in men by 66% but leave a third of cancers unaffected, prompting calls for the UK to open up its vaccination programme to adolescent boys.

The Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI)’s official interim guidance acknowledges that HPV protection could ‘provide protection against anal, penile and oropharyngeal cancers’, which would be considered as it reviewed its existing programme.

The current study suggests that, as data such as this becomes available, it may reconsider its stance on vaccinating boys. It is already investigating whether a programme vaccinating men who have sex with men would be cost-effective.

Consider vaccinating boys

If uptake in girls hits 90%, the researchers estimated that over 1,700 boys would have to be vaccinated to prevent one additional case of cancer. Uptake in girls was 87% in the UK in 2013/14.

Around 200 boys would need to be vaccinated to gain one quality-adjusted life-year (QALY), a measure of life quality used to assess value for money of a health intervention.

The authors, from VU University Amsterdam, said it was ‘appropriate’ for richer, developed countries, such as the UK, to consider vaccinating boys.

‘Inclusion of boys into pre-adolescent HPV vaccination programmes is warranted once the incremental costs of vaccination conform to society’s willingness to pay in comparison with the incremental health effects,’ they said.

They went on to add: ‘Protection of women should no longer be the sole public health objective of any HPV vaccination programme.’

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

What do plans for 50% contributions mean for your NHS pension?

What do plans for 50% contributions mean for your NHS pension?

The government is planning to consult on a proposal that would allow GPs to reduce...

50:50 pension option 'will fail' says BMA as government consults on proposal

50:50 pension option 'will fail' says BMA as government consults on proposal

The BMA has said that a plan to allow doctors to halve their pension contributions...

GPs urged to be vigilant year-round as fraud cases rock practices

GPs urged to be vigilant year-round as fraud cases rock practices

GP partners should ensure they are on top of their practice finances throughout the...

Digital-first approach in underdoctored areas risks short changing patients

Digital-first approach in underdoctored areas risks short changing patients

Plans to tackle GP shortages by allowing digital-first providers to expand in underdoctored...

GP Job of the Week: Lead GP, urgent care centre, east London

GP Job of the Week: Lead GP, urgent care centre, east London

Greenbrook Healthcare is looking to appoint a lead GP to its clinical leadership...

NHS England says it will avoid top-down approach to PCNs

NHS England says it will avoid top-down approach to PCNs

NHS England will not issue national guidance to primary care networks (PCNs) about...