Face-to-face GP visits outscore video consultations on quality and depth

GP consultations carried out face-to-face last longer, score higher for quality and involve a greater exchange of information between patients and doctors than video consultations, researchers have found.

Face-to-face consultation (Photo: sturti/Getty Images)
Face-to-face consultation (Photo: sturti/Getty Images)

Researchers studied recordings of 149 video consultations by GPs across nine practices and compared them with telephone and face-to-face appointments, in the first in-depth analysis of video consultations in primary care.

As the health service works towards a pledge in the NHS long-term plan to give all patients 'a new right' to choose digital-first primary care by 2023/24, the researchers warned that 'considerable work may be required to integrate video consultations with current NHS systems'.

Researchers from the Universities of Edinburgh, Warwick and Exeter warned that although popular with some patients, the advantages to clinicians of video consultations were 'less clear'.

The study, published in the BJGP, found that video consultations had a similar duration to telephone consultations, covered similar ground and had a comparable impact on follow-up workload.

GP consultations

But compared with face-to-face consultations, the researchers found a 'reduction of some elements of care, particularly information giving, and consultation length', which they said 'may have consequences for overall experience and effectiveness of care'.

They called for further research to investigate the implications of wider use of video consultations in the NHS, 'to determine the best role for video consultations in terms of suitability for patients and clinical conditions, and the risks and benefits associated with it'.

Although clinicians reported that face-to-face appointments were more useful for managing patients conditions than either video or telephone consultations, the study found that more than half of patients felt there were no disadvantages to either video or telephone consultations.

Professor Brian McKinstry from the University of Edinburgh said: 'Video-consulting shows great promise for straightforward problems. While missing some of the depth of face-to-face consultations, some patients may be happy to trade this off for the convenience of a doctor they can see without having to travel to the surgery or take time off work.'

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Full-time GP partners work 50% more than standard working week

Full-time GP partners work 50% more than standard working week

Full-time GP partners work on average 50% more than a standard working week, a GPonline...

Oedema - red flag symptoms

Oedema - red flag symptoms

Red flag symptoms to be aware of when a patient presents with pitting or non-pitting...

Nine in 10 doctors fear NHS staff crisis could force them into mistakes

Nine in 10 doctors fear NHS staff crisis could force them into mistakes

Nine in 10 doctors fear a 'toxic combination' of rising workload and understaffing...

Proportion of GP practices with over 20,000 patients triples in five years

Proportion of GP practices with over 20,000 patients triples in five years

The proportion of GP practices in England with over 20,000 patients has more than...

Government's 'Yellowhammer' plan for no-deal Brexit confirms NHS fears

Government's 'Yellowhammer' plan for no-deal Brexit confirms NHS fears

Medicine shortages and an even tougher winter than usual lie ahead for the NHS should...

How GP trainee numbers in England have soared over the past decade

How GP trainee numbers in England have soared over the past decade

With serious concerns over the falling full-time equivalent (FTE) GP workforce in...