Dr Chris Mimnagh: Will £20k 'golden hellos' solve the GP recruitment crisis?

Do GP trainees really want a £20k bonus or do they place more value on being in the 'right' place? Dr Chris Mimnagh wonders if financial incentives are the right way to go.

The announcement that GP registrars will get up to £20k if they go to work in under-doctored areas is being heralded as a good thing.

I’m sceptical. There’s a reason areas are under-doctored, usually because it’s hard work in a rough area with little prospect of a good quality of life for GP and patient alike.

So, would you take the bonus and go there?

Or would you prefer to work in a practice with good teamwork, a great vision of the future, success in recruiting other GPs, a great skill mix of staff, mobile (dare I say agile) working practices, family-friendly policies and not have the bonus?

Is being in the 'right' place better than being in the more financially beneficial place?

Don’t forget the next crop of registrars were usually born in the late 1980s early 1990s and achieved autonomy as millennials.

For them the world has a different flavour. They are digital natives, people who prioritise life-work balance over work-life balance, people who are more likely to work part time, have several careers and will  probably be values driven not value-for-money driven.

So if I’m dissing the money, what is the answer?

I think it’s about creating that environment that attracts, that supports, that nurtures.

Trouble is you can’t start that from a position of failure.

To rebuild general practice we will need to start again, regroup, defect free. 

Practices, councils, communities need to collaborate, recognising the finite resource and the value placed on it.

  • Dr Chris Mimnagh is a GP in Liverpool and head of clinical innovation liaison and deployment at The Innovation Agency, the academic health science network for the north-west coast.

Read more from Chris Mimnagh

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Advance decisions to refuse treatment - what GPs need to know

Advance decisions to refuse treatment - what GPs need to know

A recent case has underlined the need for GPs to communicate a patient’s known wishes...

Law changed to allow physios and paramedics to administer vaccines during pandemic

Law changed to allow physios and paramedics to administer vaccines during pandemic

A wider range of healthcare workers will be allowed to administer flu and potential...

Medicines shortages drive up GP workload as prescribing costs surge £158m

Medicines shortages drive up GP workload as prescribing costs surge £158m

Medicines shortages in England are continuing to drive up GP workload during the...

Arrhythmias - red flag symptoms

Arrhythmias - red flag symptoms

Dr Pipin Singh provides an overview of red flag symptoms in patients with arrhythmias.

How have GP practices fared under CQC inspections?

How have GP practices fared under CQC inspections?

The latest annual report from the CQC sets out ratings for all of the sectors it...

CQC flags concern over GP access despite 2m face-to-face appointments last week

CQC flags concern over GP access despite 2m face-to-face appointments last week

The CQC plans to 'follow up' concerns about access to face-to-face GP services, warning...