DoH advisers attack Darzi plans for practice ratings

Evidence that publicly ranking GP practices can improve health outcomes is almost non-existent, according to a think-tank staffed by former DoH advisers and top NHS managers.

As Lord Darzi announced plans last week to let patients rate GP surgeries' performance in a form similar to the Zagat restaurant rating system, a Health Foundation report highlighted the failure of similar schemes.

Researchers uncovered several instances in England 'where the public release of performance results could be a disincentive for improvement'. The study found that the release of performance data has spiralled in the last 10 years in the US and the UK.

The London Health Observatory is publishing practices' QOF data and iwantgreatcare.org invites patients to rate their GP. GP scorecards, originally used by PCTs as a performance management tool, are to be made public in some areas in 2009.

GPC deputy chairman Dr Richard Vautrey said that practice rating data often did not represent practices fairly.

tom.ireland@haymarket.com

Comment below and tell us what you think

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

A third of doctors have received abuse from patients during the pandemic

A third of doctors have received abuse from patients during the pandemic

One in three doctors have experienced verbal or physical abuse from patients or patients'...

Health secretary has 'overplayed his hand' on remote consultation benefits, RCGP chair warns

Health secretary has 'overplayed his hand' on remote consultation benefits, RCGP chair warns

Health secretary Matt Hancock has ‘overplayed his hand’ by pushing for total use...

GMC defers revalidation for a further 9,000 doctors due to pandemic

GMC defers revalidation for a further 9,000 doctors due to pandemic

Around 9,000 doctors who are due to revalidate between March and July 2021 will have...

NHS England praises GPs after steep rise in general practice appointments

NHS England praises GPs after steep rise in general practice appointments

NHS England primary care medical director Dr Nikki Kanani has thanked GPs and their...

Half of GPs say patients harmed by delays to care during COVID-19 pandemic

Half of GPs say patients harmed by delays to care during COVID-19 pandemic

Nearly half of GPs say patients on their list have come to harm because of delays...

Viewpoint: Test and trace isn't working - could GPs do it better?

Viewpoint: Test and trace isn't working - could GPs do it better?

The outsourced test and trace system isn't working, says Dr Simon Hodes. It's time...