Differential diagnoses - Pigmented skin lesions

Dr Nigel Stollery compares four presentations and offers clues for their diagnosis.

Compound naevus


  • Common benign pigmented naevus arising in melanocytes
  • Colour varies from white to dark brown
  • May occur congenitally
  • Usually raised above the surface of the skin
  • Size varies from 2-7mm in diameter


  • Treatment not always needed
  • Indications for removal include diagnostic uncertainty, cosmetic reasons, or if there is repeated trauma
  • Treatment of choice is surgical excision
  • Whole lesions should be removed and sent for histology

Malignant melanoma


  • Malignant skin lesion with potential to be life-threatening
  • Metastatic spread will occur if untreated
  • Incidence increasing
  • Occurs at younger age than other skin malignancies
  • More common in skin types 1 and 2 and with UV exposure
  • 30% develop in existing naevi


  • Early excision is treatment of choice
  • Whole lesions should be removed and sent for histology with 2mm margin
  • Once diagnosis is confirmed, wide excision required
  • When spread has occurred, prognosis is poor, with few treatment options

Pigmented basal cell carcinoma


  • Most common type of skin malignancy
  • Incidence increases with age
  • Occur mainly on sun-exposed areas of skin
  • When pigmented, differential includes malignant melanoma
  • Lesions have little potential for metastatic spread


  • Excision is the treatment of choice
  • Histology to check for complete excision and confirm diagnosis
  • Further lesions commonly occur
  • Advise patients on sun protection

Seborrhoeic keratosis


  • Very common benign lesions
  • Pale to dark brown in colour
  • Stuck-on appearance, with crusted warty surface
  • Incidence increases with age
  • No potential for malignant transformation
  • Typical keratin plugs and horny cysts when viewed with a lens


  • Treatment not usually necessary
  • If required, cryotherapy can be undertaken
  • Other treatments include curettage and cautery

    Dr Stollery is a GP in Kibworth, Leicestershire, and clinical assistant in dermatology at Leicester Royal Infirmary

      Have you registered with us yet?

      Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


      Already registered?

      Sign in

      Follow Us:

      Just published

      COVID-19 vaccination centre

      BMA raises 'serious concerns' about GP workload and funding for autumn COVID boosters

      The BMA has raised 'serious concerns' about the workload implications of this autumn's...


      Monkeypox jabs will run out by next week, UKHSA says

      The UK is likely to run out of smallpox vaccine stocks which it is using to protect...

      NHS sign outside a building

      Two Midlands hospitals end partnerships with Babylon

      Two NHS trusts have prematurely severed their relationships with digital health provider,...

      Person receiving a COVID-19 booster

      JCVI sets out which vaccines to use for autumn COVID-19 boosters

      The Joint Committee on Vaccinations and Immunisations (JCVI) has said that Moderna's...

      The original Moderna COVID-19 vaccine

      First COVID-19 vaccine to target Omicron variant approved for use in UK

      The MHRA has approved an updated version of the Moderna vaccine that targets both...

      Ballot box

      Majority of GPs back taking industrial action in the coming year, poll suggests

      The majority of GPs support taking industrial action in the coming 12 months to push...