DH advisers rethink decision to block HPV jabs for boys

Government advisers are reconsidering their recommendation against vaccinating boys for HPV, after appearing to admit that initial cost modelling may not have been based on real-world costs.

DH headquarters, Whitehall (Photo: Emma Platt)
DH headquarters, Whitehall (Photo: Emma Platt)

The Joint Committee for Vaccinations and Immunisations (JCVI) has postponed its final recommendation regarding whether boys should be included in the HPV vaccination programme.

It comes after the committee, which advises the government on its vaccination programmes, released an interim statement in July warning that extending the programme to boys was ‘highly unlikely to be cost effective’.

But minutes from a recent JCVI meeting suggest that the cost analyses used to determine this were calculated based on inaccurate information about vaccine pricing, which may affect the outcome.

HPV vaccine options

The JCVI added that there was more than one type of HPV vaccine available, and there was ‘potential to consider’ using HPV vaccines of differing valences for girls and boys as a cost-effective approach.

Since publication of its interim statement, the JCVI said stakeholders had also raised legal questions about whether it was discriminatory not to include boys in the vaccination programme.

The committee concluded that the modelling work needed ‘final checks, peer review and additional scenarios explored’. As a result, it said it was ‘not yet in a position to finalise its recommendation on boys’ vaccination’.

The JCVI began its assessment of vaccination for boys in 2013. Campaigners have warned that five years should be ‘more than enough time for a decision’, warning that 400,000 more boys are left unvaccinated and at risk to HPV-related every year.

The scheme vaccinating teenage girls launched almost a decade ago in 2008 to help protect them against cervical cancer.

Rethink on advice

But campaigners welcomed the news that the JCVI could be looking to change its recommendation.

HPV Action campaign director Peter Baker said: ‘While we are pleased that JCVI is listening to HPV Action and looking again at its interim decision not to vaccinate boys, we are very concerned about how long this process is taking.

‘The JCVI’s review of HPV vaccination for boys began in 2013 and a decision was supposed to have been made in 2015. The announcement was then postponed to early 2017 and now we are looking at 2018.’

Tristan Almada, co-founder of the HPV & Anal Cancer Foundation, said: ‘Although the public is familiar with the HPV vaccine as the "cervical cancer jab", HPV is responsible for the fastest increasing cancers in UK men today.

'Recognising the HPV vaccine as our best opportunity to prevent cancer since smoking cessation, 15 countries, including the US, Canada, and Australia, are now vaccinating their boys against a virus that causes cancer in both genders. UK boys deserve the same.'

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

GP Job of the Week: Lead GP, urgent care centre, east London

GP Job of the Week: Lead GP, urgent care centre, east London

Greenbrook Healthcare is looking to appoint a lead GP to its clinical leadership...

NHS England says it will avoid top-down approach to PCNs

NHS England says it will avoid top-down approach to PCNs

NHS England will not issue national guidance to primary care networks (PCNs) about...

Capita admits to further cervical screening administration errors

Capita admits to further cervical screening administration errors

The BMA has again demanded that Capita be stripped of its contract to provide GP...

GPC Wales appoints new chair

GPC Wales appoints new chair

Dr Phil White has been appointed the new chair of GPC Wales.

Nine in 10 GPs say appraisal improves patient care

Nine in 10 GPs say appraisal improves patient care

The vast majority of GPs believe annual appraisal helps to improve patient care and...

GPs have a key role to play in helping people back into work

GPs have a key role to play in helping people back into work

Brief interventions by health professionals can help people to achieve their working...