Depression might be bipolar disorder

GPs should be assessing patients with depression to rule out a diagnosis of bipolar disorder, say UK researchers.

As many as one in four patients diagnosed with depression in primary care were found to have had episodes of mania when questioned, the latest study showed.

It focused on 790 patients with a diagnosis of unipolar depression who attended a GP practice in Darlington, Cleveland.

Patients were sent the mood disorder questionnaire (MDQ). Of 278 patients who returned the questionnaire, 24 per cent had an episode of mania or mild mania. Subsequent assessment of the patients showed that half had bipolar disorder.

Lead researcher Dr Stuart Watson, from the psychiatric department of the University of Newcastle, said treating bipolar patients as though they had depression could exacerbate the condition.

'The guidelines say that bipolar patients shouldn't be on an antidepressant drug without an antimania drug,' he said.

The concern is that treating bipolar disorder with antidepressants alone can exacerbate the mania side of the disorder.

Dr Dave Tomson, a Tyneside GP who has an interest in mental health, said his practice was already trying out the MDQ.

'Some people who are being treated for depression may have bipolar disorder,' he said.

But, Dr Tomson said as bipolar disorder is not a single condition, outcomes may vary: 'What we're not sure about is how often a different diagnosis will help. It's not clear it'll help everyone.'

The latest research was presented at Faculty of General and Community Psychiatry Annual Meeting in Newcastle last week.

rachel.liddle@haymarket.com

Comment below and tell us what you think 

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Javid must offer 'clear public backing for GPs', warns BMA

Javid must offer 'clear public backing for GPs', warns BMA

The BMA has demanded 'clear public backing' for general practice from the government...

How has COVID-19 impacted on continuity of care in general practice?

How has COVID-19 impacted on continuity of care in general practice?

Dr Jessica Farrell and Dr Kamal Sidhu look at clinicians’ views of how the pandemic...

‘Sick to the back teeth of press saying we're closed’ - GPs condemn media attacks

‘Sick to the back teeth of press saying we're closed’ - GPs condemn media attacks

After media campaigns criticising GPs on face-to-face access, doctors have spoken...

Podcast: GP access row, improving menopause care, COVID-19 boosters

Podcast: GP access row, improving menopause care, COVID-19 boosters

The team discusses the current media storm around face-to-face access, COVID booster...

Face-to-face GP appointments on demand 'unachievable', warns RCGP chair

Face-to-face GP appointments on demand 'unachievable', warns RCGP chair

Calls for general practice to offer face-to-face appointments to all patients who...

Cornwall PCN wheels out electric car fleet to reduce carbon footprint

Cornwall PCN wheels out electric car fleet to reduce carbon footprint

Staff at a primary care network (PCN) in Cornwall have committed to reducing their...