Some deaneries 'could go to the wall', GPs warn

Reforms to encourage competition between deaneries could affect the quality of GP training and even mean they are forced to close, according to a leading GP.

Dr Drage says commissioner/provider split will result in NHS managers controlling GP training (Photograph: Jason Heath Lancy)
Dr Drage says commissioner/provider split will result in NHS managers controlling GP training (Photograph: Jason Heath Lancy)

SHAs were instructed by the DoH to start separating the commissioning and provision of medical education in England by April this year.

Dr Michelle Drage, joint chief executive of Londonwide LMCs, said this will effectively mean NHS managers controlling how GPs are taught, rather than deaneries.

'If you split the functions then the deanery will end up with one or none of these roles. If the commissioners are not medical commissioners, they will be SHA commissioners.

'Training then becomes driven not by what makes the best GP, but what is best for managers and their services.'

Encouraging competition between deaneries could lead to some being starved of funds, said Dr Drage.

'It is theoretically possible that some could end up going bust,' she said.

Dr Prit Chahal, chairman of the UK Association of Programme Directors (UKAPD, formerly the UK Association of Course Organisers) said encouraging competition between deaneries 'may have the reverse effect on the quality of GP training.'

'I suspect this is a manifestation of the DoH's obsession with "splits" and performance indicators, in the hope that costs will be driven down,' he said.

UKAPD vice-chairman, Dr Brad Cheek, said it raised the possibility of private companies providing GP training.

'I do not think that a commercial provider would be prepared to accept the huge range of trainees currently entering GP training and to guarantee their successful completion in three years,' he said.

Dr Richard Wakeford, a UKAPD executive member, said the 'biggest issue' was whether the new coalition government would proceed with the policy. Training posts are already being frozen by SHAs, he said.

The DoH was unavailable to comment due to the recent change of government.

NHS London said the reforms would 'ensure we have the right training for the right services', and that GP educationalists were being consulted.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

GPs to be told 'shortly' how they can reclaim PPE costs

GPs to be told 'shortly' how they can reclaim PPE costs

Information on how practices will be reimbursed for PPE costs incurred during the...

GPs demand support as COVID hotspots sound alarm over rising workload

GPs demand support as COVID hotspots sound alarm over rising workload

GP leaders have accused the government of 'behaving as if the second wave is an unexpected...

Abusive graffiti daubed on side of GP practice in Bristol

Abusive graffiti daubed on side of GP practice in Bristol

GPs at a practice in Bristol arrived at work this week to find abusive graffiti daubed...

GP capacity hit hard as 60% lost colleagues to self-isolation in past fortnight

GP capacity hit hard as 60% lost colleagues to self-isolation in past fortnight

More than three in five GPs say they or clinical colleagues have been forced to self-isolate...

GPs feel like 'boiling frogs' as abuse over face-to-face appointments continues

GPs feel like 'boiling frogs' as abuse over face-to-face appointments continues

GPs are continuing to face unkindness, verbal abuse and complaints - leaving staff...

GPs place first orders from government flu jab reserve as £12m support fund rolled out

GPs place first orders from government flu jab reserve as £12m support fund rolled out

GP practices can start ordering flu vaccine from an 8m-dose government stockpile...