CQC 'disappointed' after fury over practice risk ranking

The CQC has said it is disappointed by the reaction to its publication of practice risk ratings that will be used to decide which GP surgeries should be inspected first.

Medical centre: CQC disappointed over reporting of its risk tool (Photo: Robert Johns/UNP)
Medical centre: CQC disappointed over reporting of its risk tool (Photo: Robert Johns/UNP)

A spokesman for the watchdog told GP it had tried to mitigate the risk of information from its 'intelligent monitoring' tool being presented as a league table and had briefed the media on how it should be interpreted.

The publication on Monday of details of its system for targeting inspections at high-risk practices first provoked fury from GPs.

Using data from the QOF, patient surveys and other publicly available information, the CQC ranked practices on a scale from band 1 (highest risk) to band six (lowest risk).

Practice risk ratings published

A map available on the CQC website shows the risk band allocated to every GP practice in the country, with those in the highest risk bands likely to be inspected first.

Inspections of GP practices under the revamped CQC inspection scheme began in October – but at the time the CQC unveiled its risk tool, just two practices had been handed official ratings by the watchdog, both of them ‘outstanding’.

CQC said publishing the perceived risk level data was not a judgment of service quality.

But scores of media outlets across England responded by highlighting ‘high risk’ practices in their area based on which risk band the CQC has placed them in. The Daily Mail reported that one in six practices were failing.

One CQC official insisted on Twitter that assigning practices a number on a scale of one to six based on perceived risk level was 'not ranking', suggesting the media had failed to report the information sensibly.

GPC member and Birmingham LMC executive secretary Dr Robert Morley responded: "So CQC expected the Daily Mail to report this sensibly?’

A CQC spokesman said the watchdog did not have control over the media and it was ‘disappointing that despite our best efforts, our analysis has been misrepresented to suggest that practices are failing – we do not support this accusation’. 

He added: ‘We are clear that our judgements of general practices can only be formed once we have carried out an inspection. We are keen to demonstrate outstanding practice when we find it, including by highlighting the first two practices to be awarded with this rating two days ago.’

The spokesman added that CQC had 'worked closely with GPs, listening and acting on their feedback in creating this tool'.

Dr Morley has called the publication of the data a ‘huge-cock-up, symptomatic of the CQC’.

Risk tool questioned

He questioned the fitness for purpose of the indicators used by the watchdog to place practices in bands.

‘Lots of the data aren’t in any way a good means of determining the quality of care a practice gives – they are out of context, they might be related to issues that are out of practice control, and might reflect retired QOF indicators.

‘But having made the decision to use this information, it should just have been an internal tool to prioritise visits.

‘It doesn’t make any sense to publish these as a ranking on a website available to the public and the media.’

He said suggestions that practices were failing based on this data were ‘disgraceful’.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

Patient receiving flu vaccination

GP practices denied funding to vaccinate their own staff against flu

GPs have hit out at NHS England over a 'maddeningly frustrating' failure to offer...

BMA junior doctor strike action in 2016

Junior doctors to be balloted on industrial action in early January

The BMA looks set to ballot junior doctors in England on industrial action in early...

BMA sign

BMA sets up first-ever ‘strike fund’ to support industrial action

The BMA is about to release £2m from its reserves to pay for possible ballots on...

Dozens of GPs with suicidal thoughts contact specialist service every month

A specialist mental health service for doctors is being contacted by dozens of GPs...

GP consultation

GPs demand this summer 'matched pre-pandemic winter'

General practice needs urgent support to cope with spiralling demand after appointments...

Talking General Practice

Podcast: Looking after GP mental health at a time of crisis

We speak to Dr Helen Garr, medical director of NHS Practitioner Health, about the...