Controversial plans scrapped as reports question how NHS uses data

The DH has announced that the programme will be axed following publication of two reviews into how data is used and shared in the NHS.

Two reviews commissioned by the DH were published on Wednesday – the Review of Data Security, Consent and Opt-Outs from national data guardian (NDG) Dame Fiona Caldicott and the Safe data, safe care report from the CQC.

Health minister George Freeman said NHS England had taken the decision to ‘close the programme’ in light of the findings.

But he warned that the NHS must match the pace of modern life and become ‘fully digital’, with GP, pharmacy and hospital records all based on digital platforms.

NHS data

The Caldicott review concluded that trust in the way personal data is used by the NHS ‘has been eroded’ and work must be done to engage them and show them the benefits of data sharing.

It made 20 recommendations to the DH designed to strengthen safeguards for keeping health and care information secure and ensuring the public can make informed choices on how their data is used.

Among these, it calls for the DH to implement harsher sanctions in place to prevent malicious data breaches and for CCGs to provide evidence they taking action to improve cyber security and identify any vulnerabilities.

It added that the CQC should ‘amend its inspection framework’ to take a stricter assurance that practices and other services are adhering to data security standards.

CQC inspection

It also recommended that a new consent/opt out model should be adopted to allow people to opt out of their personal confidential data being used for purposes beyond their direct care – even if they previously gave permission.

Although not explicitly looked at by the review, it advised that, in light of its findings, the government should ‘consider the future of the programme’.

‘Everyone who uses health and care services should be able to trust that their personal confidential data is protected,’ Dame Fiona said.

‘Unfortunately trust in the use of personal confidential data has been eroded and steps need to be taken to demonstrate trustworthiness and ensure that the public can have confidence in the system.’ scrapped

Mr Freeman said: ‘I can confirm today that the government is supportive of the introduction of stronger criminal sanctions against those who use anonymised data to re-identify individuals.’

He added: ‘In light of Dame Fiona’s recommendations, NHS England has taken the decision to close the programme.

‘However, the government and the health and care system remain absolutely committed to realising the benefits of sharing information, as an essential part of improving outcomes for patients.

‘Therefore this work will now be taken forward by the National Information Board, in close collaboration with the primary care community, in order to retain public confidence and to drive better care for patients.’

Reacting to the Caldicott report, Professor Nigel Mathers, honorary secretary for the RCGP, said: ‘The NHS must be beyond reproach when it comes to the use of patient data for any purpose, so Dame Fiona is right to say that further steps must be taken to build public trust for the use of their information and we welcome her call for a much fuller conversation with the public.’

Read more about the proposed data security standards on Medeconomics

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

GP on phone in recorded consultation assessment

Consultation skills to help GP trainees pass the RCA

Dr Afsar Rizvi highlights the key skills GP trainees need to master in order to pass...

Wes Streeting

Labour promises same GP 'each appointment' and face-to-face access if patients want it

A Labour government would offer patients the chance to see 'the same doctor each...

Man wearing mask on train

UK faces serious threat from flu and COVID-19 'twindemic' this winter

There are strong indications the UK faces a dangerous 'twindemic' of COVID-19 and...

NHS sign outside a building

PCN contract overhaul defers two-week appointment target until April 2023

NHS England has announced changes to the network contract DES, including deferring...


NHS sets out priorities for extra GP funding this winter

Integrated care boards could target extra funding for general practice at phone systems,...

Shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves

Labour promises to double medical school places with tax cut reversal

A Labour government would double medical school places with funding raised from reversing...