Commercial slimming clubs cheaper than NHS programmes

Commercial slimming clubs are cheaper and more effective than NHS weight-loss programmes, a University of Birmingham team has found.

The researchers looked at outcomes for three commercial slimming clubs and three NHS programmes: primary care nurse-led counselling, pharmacy-based counselling and group-based dietetics.

All these groups were compared against a control group who were all given 12 vouchers for free leisure centre use but received no other intervention.

At 12 weeks, all three commercial programmes (Rosemary Conley, Slimming World and Weight Watchers) achieved weight loss beyond that seen in the control group, but none of the NHS programmes did.

At one year, only the Weight Watchers programme was able to achieve weight loss beyond that seen in the control group.

The nurse-led and pharmacy-based counselling did not achieve sustained weight loss at one year.

The researchers calculated that, at around £55 for a 12-session course, commercial programmes provided better value for money than funding NHS programmes.

Professor Paul Aveyard, who led the research, said the findings represented ‘a significant step forward’ in assessing weight-loss services’ relative quality and value.

‘Its conclusions should be of significant interest to commissioners: of all the services we tested from both the NHS and commercial providers, at programme end only the commercial programmes had significantly greater weight loss than those patients who were left to "go it alone".’

A spokesman for Weight Watchers said the results provided ‘a clear message for GP commissioners about how to achieve value for money in commissioning weight management programmes, at a time where they're being asked to deliver more for less with regard to public health outcomes’.

The study’s findings were presented at the European Conference on Obesity last week.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

GMC sanction 12 times more likely for doctors who do badly in postgrad exams

GMC sanction 12 times more likely for doctors who do badly in postgrad exams

Doctors who perform poorly in postgraduate professional exams are twelve times more...

GP indemnity costs set to rise under government regulation plans

GP indemnity costs set to rise under government regulation plans

GPs could face increased costs under plans to regulate provision of medical indemnity,...

New vitamin D guidelines aim to provide clarity on testing and prescribing

New vitamin D guidelines aim to provide clarity on testing and prescribing

Dr Terry Aspray explains what the National Osteoporosis Society's new clinical guidelines...

GPs deliver more than 1m appointments a day, official data show

GPs deliver more than 1m appointments a day, official data show

GPs across England delivered a total of 307.4m appointments in the year to 31 October...

GP practices face data protection fines worth hundreds of pounds

GP practices face data protection fines worth hundreds of pounds

GP practices are among hundreds of organisations threatened with cash fines for failing...

Heavy workload 'driving up GP referrals and preventing accurate diagnosis'

Heavy workload 'driving up GP referrals and preventing accurate diagnosis'

Heavy workload is forcing GPs to refer more patients to hospital while undermining...