‘CMO's report likely to demoralise profession'

The GMC's longest-serving council member has launched a stinging attack on the CMO Sir Liam Donaldson's review of medical regulation.

In an independent response to each of the CMO’s 44 recommendations in ‘Good Doctors Safer Patients’, Bolton GP Dr Krishna Korlipara, who has served on the GMC council for over 20 years, warned against treating ‘the vast majority of doctors like potential criminals’,  ‘demoralising the medical profession’ and also ‘undermining the good doctor-patient relationship’.  

He said that the principles that the CMO’s report are based on are good, but his conclusions from them are ‘flawed in many respects’.  

‘His most controversial recommendation relates to the burden of proof lowered from a criminal standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt to a balance of probabilities,’ said Dr Korlipara.  

‘This principle is enshrined in law both in the UK as well as throughout the EU. A threat to a doctor’s career is like the loss of liberty to an ordinary citizen.  

‘No doctor should lose their registration or licence to practise based on allegations not proved beyond reasonable doubt. Doctors are entitled to the same principles of fairness afforded  other citizens of society.’  

He said the recommendation for ‘GMC affiliates’ in each PCT ‘carries with it a real risk of inconsistent decision-making within the same locality, as well as across the different regions’.  

He added that if local doctors are selected to be the affiliates, there is a likelihood of conflict of interest with many locally known doctors.  

He also heavily criticised plans for recertification and revalidation, saying that they will simply duplicate appraisals and test knowledge, but not actual performance.  

However, his report is not universally opposed to the CMO’s recommendations and offers support on a number of issues.  

Dr Korlipara agreed the GMC should become accountable to parliament and that an expert group is established to ‘examine the use of financial incentives to promote safer practice’.  

He also agreed that adjudication in fitness-to-practise cases should be undertaken by a completely independent tribunal.  

Although the GMC has no control on the panel’s decisions, currently there is a mechanism in place for the panel chairmen to be interviewed by the president. 

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Woman holding face in pain

Should GPs treat patients presenting with dental problems?

The MDU's Dr Kathryn Leask considers what GPs should do if a patient presents with...

Conservative Party leadership candidate and foreign secretary Liz Truss

Liz Truss vows to resolve GP pension tax crisis if she becomes prime minister

Liz Truss has affirmed her commitment to resolving the GP pensions crisis but has...

Baby receiving a vaccine in their thigh

JCVI advises changes to routine childhood and HPV immunisation schedules

The Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI) has recommended a change...

GP consultation

General practice delivering 'up to double the appointments it is paid for'

General practice in England may be delivering as many as double the number of appointments...

Sign outside BMA House

GP suicide sparks calls for measures to protect doctors from spiralling workloads

The government and policymakers must do more to safeguard doctors and NHS staff from...

Talking General Practice logo

Podcast: Living with long COVID

In August we’re bringing you some of the best interviews from series one of the podcast....