CMO revises standard of proof plans

The CMO for England, Sir Liam Donaldson, has backed a sliding scale of proof in fitness-to-practise cases, following a campaign by GPs.

Arguments have raged since the CMO’s review of regulation suggested in July that the standard of proof should be lowered from a criminal standard of proof, beyond reasonable doubt, to a balance of probabilities.

But speaking at a King’s Fund event in London this week, Sir Liam suggested that minor judgments would be based on probability and only the most serious judged by criminal standards.

‘If you go with the civil standard you would have to have a sliding scale of proof,’ he told delegates.

The GMC was to debate the sliding scale this week.

GPC chairman Dr Hamish Meldrum welcomed the climbdown, saying that a sliding scale already existed to some degree.

CMO's consultation

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:

Just published

Communication failures 'stopping GPs doing their jobs', PCN leaders warn

Communication failures 'stopping GPs doing their jobs', PCN leaders warn

'Poorly executed' communications from NHS and government officials are preventing...

Oxford COVID vaccine is up to 90% effective, latest data reveal

Oxford COVID vaccine is up to 90% effective, latest data reveal

The COVID-19 vaccine developed by the University of Oxford has been shown to be 70.4%...

GPs expect major COVID vaccination role as soon as first doses are ready

GPs expect major COVID vaccination role as soon as first doses are ready

GPs are expecting to be heavily involved in delivering COVID-19 vaccination in England...

GP phone lines 'jammed' as flu jab expansion comes without warning

GP phone lines 'jammed' as flu jab expansion comes without warning

Practices have reported phone lines being 'jammed' with a deluge of calls from patients...

Scottish GPs to play 'key role' in COVID vaccine programme run by health boards

Scottish GPs to play 'key role' in COVID vaccine programme run by health boards

GPs in Scotland are to play a 'key role' in a COVID-19 vaccination programme expected...

Pandemic offers one-off chance to reform NHS culture and retain doctors, says GMC chair

Pandemic offers one-off chance to reform NHS culture and retain doctors, says GMC chair

The COVID-19 pandemic is a one-off opportunity to create a more compassionate work...